Uploaded image for project: 'Jenkins'
  1. Jenkins
  2. JENKINS-24537

No e-mail when using other/template post-build steps

XMLWordPrintable

      We have several jobs which share Post-Build Actions.
      All jobs are MultiConfiguration Jobs.

      A main job (Let's call it e.g. MyMainJob) actually acts as a template job.
      The other (secondary) jobs use the Post-Build Actions from MyMainJob.

      1. When the main job build fails e-mail notifications are sent properly. We see info in the console output.
      2. When one of the other (secondary) jobs fails, the e-mail notifications are not sent. Nothing is shown in the console output either.

      Same count for any other e-mail that's supposed to be sent (Fixed, Unstable, ...)

      Relevant configuration of the email-ext is:

      • Fixed Project Recipient List
      • Attach Build Log: _Compress and Attach Build log
      • Trigger for matrix projects: Trigger only parent job
      • Triggers:
        • Failure - 1st (using default config)
        • Failure - Still (using default config)
        • Failure -> Unstable (Test Failures) (using default config)
        • Unstable (Test Failures) - 1st (using default config)
        • Unstable (Test Failures) - Still (using default config)
        • Unstable (Test Failures)/Failure -> Success (using default config)
      • other settings: default config

          [JENKINS-24537] No e-mail when using other/template post-build steps

          Tom Ghyselinck created issue -
          Tom Ghyselinck made changes -
          Component/s Original: emailext-template [ 18764 ]

          Daniel Beck added a comment -

          Template Project Plugin, or what is this about?

          Daniel Beck added a comment - Template Project Plugin, or what is this about?

          Alex Earl added a comment -

          If this is Template Project Plugin stuff as Daniel asked about, then its not an issue with email-ext, you would need to work with the Template Project Plugin devs to determine the issue.

          Alex Earl added a comment - If this is Template Project Plugin stuff as Daniel asked about, then its not an issue with email-ext, you would need to work with the Template Project Plugin devs to determine the issue.

          Tom Ghyselinck added a comment -

          Hi,

          Thank you for the quick reply!

          No idea which plugin is causing the issue (Email-ext, MultiConfigurationJob, Template Project Plugin, ...).

          Quick summary:

          • Create MultiConfigurationJob mainJob
            • Use Email-ext in the Post-build Actions
          • Create MultiConfigurationJob secondaryJob
            • Use Post-build Actions from other Job -> select mainJob
          • In the mainJob, the e-mails are triggered / sent correctly, the secondaryJob doesn't show anything in the console from the email-ext plugin, neither are there e-mails sent.

          I hope this helps you guys decide where this should go,
          at least I will also add the template-plugin to the Components to trigger those developers...

          Thank you in advance!

          Tom Ghyselinck added a comment - Hi, Thank you for the quick reply! No idea which plugin is causing the issue ( Email-ext , MultiConfigurationJob , Template Project Plugin , ...). Quick summary: Create MultiConfigurationJob mainJob Use Email-ext in the Post-build Actions Create MultiConfigurationJob secondaryJob Use Post-build Actions from other Job -> select mainJob In the mainJob , the e-mails are triggered / sent correctly, the secondaryJob doesn't show anything in the console from the email-ext plugin, neither are there e-mails sent. I hope this helps you guys decide where this should go, at least I will also add the template-plugin to the Components to trigger those developers... Thank you in advance!
          Tom Ghyselinck made changes -
          Component/s New: template-project [ 15623 ]
          Labels Original: email-ext notification template New: email-ext multi-configuration notification template

          Alex Earl added a comment -

          This needs to be addressed by the template project plugin first.

          Alex Earl added a comment - This needs to be addressed by the template project plugin first.
          Alex Earl made changes -
          Assignee Original: Alex Earl [ slide_o_mix ]

          Alex Earl added a comment -

          I'm unable to reproduce this. I didn't setup a multiconfig job, but I did setup a template job and it worked just fine.

          Alex Earl added a comment - I'm unable to reproduce this. I didn't setup a multiconfig job, but I did setup a template job and it worked just fine.

          Alex Earl added a comment -

          Looks like it is specific to a multiconfiguration job. I created one and indeed, email-ext doesn't get called at all. Since email-ext doesn't get called, I don't think this is related to email-ext itself. It looks like template plugin's ProxyPublisher doesn't implement MatrixAggregatable, which may mean it won't work for multiconfiguration projects at all.

          Alex Earl added a comment - Looks like it is specific to a multiconfiguration job. I created one and indeed, email-ext doesn't get called at all. Since email-ext doesn't get called, I don't think this is related to email-ext itself. It looks like template plugin's ProxyPublisher doesn't implement MatrixAggregatable, which may mean it won't work for multiconfiguration projects at all.

            huybrechts huybrechts
            tom_ghyselinck Tom Ghyselinck
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated: