-
Bug
-
Resolution: Fixed
-
Major
-
Jenkins v. 1.554.2
PMD Plugin v. 3.38.
Static Code Analysis Plugins v. 1.58
Hello.
I've got a problem with computing new warnings functional.
When I add a new PMD rule to my ruleset, I get odd results.
Test case:
- Start the first build.
See summary
and full results. - Add a new PMD rule to rule set and start the second build.
Rule 'LongVariable' was added. The summary contains only 192 new warnings instead of 267 (==3126-2859).
Moreover, full result contains 267 warning for new 'LongVariable' rule (match against first result). - Go to job configuration, check 'Use delta for new warnings' check box and start the third build.
The result changed.
The summary contains both 192 and 267 new warnings on the same page.
Besides, link '267 new warnings' opens a page with 192 new warnings.
I suppose that the number of new warning should always be 267 in the example.
- is related to
-
-
- Open
-
[JENKINS-24873] Wrong number of new warnings
| Description |
Original:
ello. I've got a problem with computing new warnings functional. When I add a new PMD rule to my ruleset, I get odd results. Test case: # Start the first build. See [summary|^build_1_sum.png] and [full|^build_1_full.png] results. # Add a new PMD rule to rule set and start the second build. Rule 'LongVariable' was added. The [summary|^build_2_sum.png] contains only 192 new warnings instead of 267 (==[3126|^build_2_sum.png]-[2859|^build_1_sum.png]). Moreover, [full|^build_2_full.png] result contains 267 warning for new 'LongVariable' rule (match against [first result|^build_1_full.png]). # Go to job configuration, check 'Use delta for new warnings' check box and start the third build. The result changed. The [summary|^build_3_sum.png] contains both 192 and 267 new warnings on the same page. Besides, link '267 new warnings' opens a page with 192 new warnings. I suppose that the number of new warning should always be 267 in the example. |
New:
Hello. I've got a problem with computing new warnings functional. When I add a new PMD rule to my ruleset, I get odd results. Test case: # Start the first build. See [summary|^build_1_sum.png] and [full|^build_1_full.png] results. # Add a new PMD rule to rule set and start the second build. Rule 'LongVariable' was added. The [summary|^build_2_sum.png] contains only 192 new warnings instead of 267 (==[3126|^build_2_sum.png]-[2859|^build_1_sum.png]). Moreover, [full|^build_2_full.png] result contains 267 warning for new 'LongVariable' rule (match against [first result|^build_1_full.png]). # Go to job configuration, check 'Use delta for new warnings' check box and start the third build. The result changed. The [summary|^build_3_sum.png] contains both 192 and 267 new warnings on the same page. Besides, link '267 new warnings' opens a page with 192 new warnings. I suppose that the number of new warning should always be 267 in the example. |
| Environment |
Original:
Jenkins v. 1.554.2 PMD Plugin v. 3.38. Analysis Collector Plugin v. 1.58 |
New:
Jenkins v. 1.554.2 PMD Plugin v. 3.38. Static Code Analysis Plugins v. 1.58 |
| Link | New: This issue is related to JENKINS-6675 [ JENKINS-6675 ] |
Hello, Ulli.
What kind of properties are you talking about?
Same type, filename, line, ... Currently all warnings are collected in a set which does not contain duplicates.
Code changed in jenkins
User: Ulli Hafner
Path:
src/main/java/hudson/plugins/analysis/core/FilesParser.java
src/main/java/hudson/plugins/analysis/core/ParserResult.java
http://jenkins-ci.org/commit/analysis-core-plugin/1d1eb5b17cc4fa21043fe8332599b66ab1e17334
Log:
Merge pull request #21 from sschuberth/master
Fix checking for duplicate annotations. (Maybe related to JENKINS-24873).
Compare: https://github.com/jenkinsci/analysis-core-plugin/compare/a5cae3ab9dfd...1d1eb5b17cc4
I see. Seems that some new warnings have the same properties and are therefore marked as duplicates.