• Type: New Feature
• Resolution: Duplicate
• Priority: Minor
• Component/s: pretested-integration-plugin
• Labels:

  None
• Environment:

  Jenkins 1.545
  Jenkins GIT plugin 2.2.9
  Pretested integration plugin 2.1.2
  JDK 1.7.0_45
  os Linux amd64 2.6.32-5
  

[JENKINS-25805] Support for maven projects type (our case 12361)

Al Ferguson created issue - 2014-11-26 16:37

Al Ferguson made changes - 2014-11-26 16:38

Description

Original: Section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. While the 'Pretested Integration post-build is available in the Add post-build action dropdown, section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. Why 'Use pretested integration' doesn't show up? Conflict with another plugin? Something missing?

New: Section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. While the 'Pretested Integration post-build' is available in the 'Add post-build action' dropdown, section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. Why 'Use pretested integration' doesn't show up? Conflict with another plugin? Something missing?

Al Ferguson made changes - 2014-11-26 16:49

Description

Original: Section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. While the 'Pretested Integration post-build' is available in the 'Add post-build action' dropdown, section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. Why 'Use pretested integration' doesn't show up? Conflict with another plugin? Something missing?

New: For "maven2/3 projects" (ok for "free-style software projects"...). Section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. While the 'Pretested Integration post-build' is available in the 'Add post-build action' dropdown, section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. Why 'Use pretested integration' doesn't show up? Conflict with another plugin? Something missing?

Al Ferguson made changes - 2014-11-26 16:50

Description

Original: For "maven2/3 projects" (ok for "free-style software projects"...). Section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. While the 'Pretested Integration post-build' is available in the 'Add post-build action' dropdown, section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. Why 'Use pretested integration' doesn't show up? Conflict with another plugin? Something missing?

New: For "maven2/3 projects" only (ok for "free-style software projects"). Section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. While the 'Pretested Integration post-build' is available in the 'Add post-build action' dropdown, section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. Why 'Use pretested integration' doesn't show up? Conflict with another plugin? Something missing?

Al Ferguson made changes - 2014-11-26 16:50

Description

Original: For "maven2/3 projects" only (ok for "free-style software projects"). Section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. While the 'Pretested Integration post-build' is available in the 'Add post-build action' dropdown, section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. Why 'Use pretested integration' doesn't show up? Conflict with another plugin? Something missing?

New: For "maven2/3 projects" only (ok for "free-style software projects"). Section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page of "maven2/3 projects". While the 'Pretested Integration post-build' is available in the 'Add post-build action' dropdown, section 'Use pretested integration' does not appear in the Job configuration page. Why 'Use pretested integration' doesn't show up? Conflict with another plugin? Something missing?

Al Ferguson made changes - 2014-11-26 16:59

Summary

Original: 'Use pretested integration' doesn't show up

New: 'Use pretested integration' doesn't show up for maven projects

Collapse comment: Daniel Beck added a comment - 2014-11-26 19:14

Daniel Beck added a comment - 2014-11-26 19:14

The build wrapper is deliberately only available in Freestyle projects:
https://github.com/jenkinsci/pretested-integration-plugin/blob/master/src/main/java/org/jenkinsci/plugins/pretestedintegration/PretestedIntegrationBuildWrapper.java#L186

Therefore reducing priority as it's probably just the publisher showing up when it shouldn't, and it's easy enough to prevent that:

For those plugins that don't want Publisher to show up in different job type, use BuildStepDescriptor for the base type of your descriptor to control which job type it supports.

Expand comment: Daniel Beck added a comment - 2014-11-26 19:14

Daniel Beck added a comment - 2014-11-26 19:14 The build wrapper is deliberately only available in Freestyle projects: https://github.com/jenkinsci/pretested-integration-plugin/blob/master/src/main/java/org/jenkinsci/plugins/pretestedintegration/PretestedIntegrationBuildWrapper.java#L186 Therefore reducing priority as it's probably just the publisher showing up when it shouldn't, and it's easy enough to prevent that: For those plugins that don't want Publisher to show up in different job type, use BuildStepDescriptor for the base type of your descriptor to control which job type it supports.

Daniel Beck made changes - 2014-11-26 19:14

Priority

Original: Blocker [ 1 ]

New: Minor [ 4 ]

Bue Petersen made changes - 2014-11-27 08:04

Summary

Original: 'Use pretested integration' doesn't show up for maven projects

New: 'Use pretested integration' doesn't show up for maven projects (our case 12361)

Collapse comment: Bue Petersen added a comment - 2014-11-27 08:13, Edited by Bue Petersen - 2014-11-27 08:22

Bue Petersen added a comment - 2014-11-27 08:13 - edited

Hi

Thanks for raising the issue Al, and Daniel thanks for the clarification.

It was a specific decision to support Freestyle projects to start with, as that was what most of our customers uses. I don't see there should any problems extending it later to support other types of projects, but it require us to do add more testing at least.

I have created issues JENKINS-25810 about only showing the post build step for supported job types.

So now we can consider this issue as a feature request to support Maven job types in the plugin.

Expand comment: Bue Petersen added a comment - 2014-11-27 08:13, Edited by Bue Petersen - 2014-11-27 08:22

Bue Petersen added a comment - 2014-11-27 08:13 - edited Hi Thanks for raising the issue Al, and Daniel thanks for the clarification. It was a specific decision to support Freestyle projects to start with, as that was what most of our customers uses. I don't see there should any problems extending it later to support other types of projects, but it require us to do add more testing at least. I have created issues JENKINS-25810 about only showing the post build step for supported job types. So now we can consider this issue as a feature request to support Maven job types in the plugin.

Load more newer events