-
Bug
-
Resolution: Cannot Reproduce
-
Major
-
Jenkins 1.6.14
Workflow 1.6
Win32 JNLP slaves
Create slaves with 1 executor, labels, and "Only build jobs with label restrictions matching this node." Create a build with a dozen long-running parallel steps that contain a node step which match the slave labels. Of about 10% of the builds executed, Workflow will spawn a 2nd executor on one of these slaves, as evidenced by a 2nd workspace folder, despite only having 1 executor available.
- is related to
-
-
- Open
-
[JENKINS-28604] Parallel step with node blocks for the same agent will create 2nd executor on single-executor slaves
A C
created issue -
I don't have the time right now to write a full test case, but here's a cut-down version of the idiom I am trying to use, hopefully helpful:
- 1 restricted master executor with no labels, 2 restricted slaves with labels and 1 executor each (restricted = only run jobs with matching labels)
try {
parallel {
node( 'slave' )
<repeat node( 'slave' ) several times>
}
} catch( Exception e ) {
node( 'slave' )
throw e
}
A C
added a comment - - edited I don't have the time right now to write a full test case, but here's a cut-down version of the idiom I am trying to use, hopefully helpful:
1 restricted master executor with no labels, 2 restricted slaves with labels and 1 executor each (restricted = only run jobs with matching labels)
try {
parallel {
node( 'slave' )
{
<batch step that fails>
}
<repeat node( 'slave' ) several times>
}
} catch( Exception e ) {
node( 'slave' )
{
<another batch step that fails>
}
throw e
} A C
added a comment - After browsing the bug DB some more, one other potentially relevant note - these slaves do have a high latency connection to the master, on the order of many seconds to (rarely) a few minutes.
A C
added a comment - After browsing the bug DB some more, one other potentially relevant note - these slaves do have a high latency connection to the master, on the order of many seconds to (rarely) a few minutes. | Link | New: This issue is related to JENKINS-28759 [ JENKINS-28759 ] |
| Labels | New: windows |
| Workflow | Original: JNJira [ 163450 ] | New: JNJira + In-Review [ 181243 ] |
| Component/s | New: pipeline-general [ 21692 ] |
Workflow 1.7 has made this problem worse. Now whenever a slave fails a long running process, Workflow tries to run all the queued parallel builds at once when the node is freed, and generates a new workspace for each one - so I end up with 6 workspaces on a slave machine that only has 1 executor.
This is sometimes, but not always correlated with Workflow hanging on a batchfile step that failed.
From the outside, this partly looks like a race condition in node assignment for parallel steps.