jglick The consoleText API does not include timestamps generated by this plugin, so it's not an option.
stevengbrown /timestamps API would require two HTTP requests from a external tool (one to consoleText and a second one to /timestamps) which is a weird way to get a simple log file with timestamps (and probably not doable with most of the log analysis tools, which require direct access to the log file).
The proposed PR didn't break anything, since the time selector menu is hidden when you use -Dtimestamper-consolenotes-plain=true, so the user would be who decides if he wants the full feature set or a plain timestamp in the log file (which is the most common use case in the Java world).
I'm missing this feature, but... your plugin, your rules, of course.
PR sent: https://github.com/jenkinsci/timestamper-plugin/pull/16