-
Bug
-
Resolution: Fixed
-
Minor
-
None
Original reporter https://github.com/mrcarlosrendon
Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed
<entry> <title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated> </entry>
<entry> <title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated> </entry>
They are for two different projects, but the <id> tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses.
I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue.
- is duplicated by
-
-
- Resolved
-
[JENKINS-32232] RSS entry IDs are not unique for nested items (folders, multibranch projects, etc)
| Description |
Original:
Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed ```xml <entry> <title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated> </entry> ``` ```xml <entry> <title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated> </entry> ``` They are for two different projects, but the ```<id>``` tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses. I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue. |
New:
Original reporter https://github.com/mrcarlosrendon Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed ```xml <entry> <title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated> </entry> ``` ```xml <entry> <title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated> </entry> ``` They are for two different projects, but the ```<id>``` tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses. I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue. |
| Description |
Original:
Original reporter https://github.com/mrcarlosrendon Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed ```xml <entry> <title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated> </entry> ``` ```xml <entry> <title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated> </entry> ``` They are for two different projects, but the ```<id>``` tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses. I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue. |
New:
Original reporter https://github.com/mrcarlosrendon Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed {code:xml} <entry> <title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated> </entry> {code} {code:xml} <entry> <title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated> </entry> {code} They are for two different projects, but the ```<id>``` tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses. I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue. |
| Component/s | New: cloudbees-folder-plugin [ 18137 ] | |
| Component/s | New: core [ 15593 ] |
| Labels | New: multibranch nested |
| Description |
Original:
Original reporter https://github.com/mrcarlosrendon Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed {code:xml} <entry> <title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated> </entry> {code} {code:xml} <entry> <title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated> </entry> {code} They are for two different projects, but the ```<id>``` tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses. I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue. |
New:
Original reporter https://github.com/mrcarlosrendon Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed {code:xml} <entry> <title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated> </entry> {code} {code:xml} <entry> <title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title> <link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/> <id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id> <published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published> <updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated> </entry> {code} They are for two different projects, but the {{<id>}} tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses. I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue. |
Reference: https://github.com/jenkinsci/jenkins/blob/9ab3f1d6aa15a242d226b45664bbb1a8dd0c9818/core/src/main/java/hudson/model/Run.java#L2397 probably just needs a getFullName() instead.
| Component/s | Original: cloudbees-folder-plugin [ 18137 ] | |
| Component/s | Original: multi-branch-project-plugin [ 21127 ] | |
| Labels | Original: multibranch nested |
Would something like tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:foo/bar/trunk:19 be a valid ID? That would be trivial to do, but RFC 3987 is a bit more than I'd like to deal with right now.