[JENKINS-32232] RSS entry IDs are not unique for nested items (folders, multibranch projects, etc)

Type: Bug
Resolution: Fixed
Priority: Minor
Component/s: core
Labels:
None

Similar Issues:
Powered by SuggestiMate

Show

Original reporter https://github.com/mrcarlosrendon

Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed

<entry>
<title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated>
</entry>

<entry>
<title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated>
</entry>

They are for two different projects, but the <id> tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses.

I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue.

is duplicated by

JENKINS-34767 RSS ID duplication for items with same name in different folders

Resolved

Matthew DeTullio created issue - 2015-12-30 23:38

Matthew DeTullio made changes - 2015-12-31 00:02

Description

Original: Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed

```xml
<entry>
<title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated>
</entry>
```

```xml
<entry>
<title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated>
</entry>
```

They are for two different projects, but the ```<id>``` tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses.

I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue.

New: Original reporter https://github.com/mrcarlosrendon

Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed

```xml
<entry>
<title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated>
</entry>
```

```xml
<entry>
<title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated>
</entry>
```

They are for two different projects, but the ```<id>``` tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses.

I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue.

Matthew DeTullio made changes - 2015-12-31 00:02

Description

Original: Original reporter https://github.com/mrcarlosrendon

Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed

```xml
<entry>
<title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated>
</entry>
```

```xml
<entry>
<title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated>
</entry>
```

They are for two different projects, but the ```<id>``` tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses.

I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue.

New: Original reporter https://github.com/mrcarlosrendon

Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed

{code:xml}
<entry>
<title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated>
</entry>
{code}

{code:xml}
<entry>
<title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated>
</entry>
{code}

They are for two different projects, but the ```<id>``` tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses.

I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue.

Matthew DeTullio made changes - 2015-12-31 00:03

Component/s		New: cloudbees-folder-plugin [ 18137 ]
Component/s		New: core [ 15593 ]

Matthew DeTullio made changes - 2015-12-31 00:03

Labels

New: multibranch nested

Matthew DeTullio made changes - 2015-12-31 00:33

Description

Original: Original reporter https://github.com/mrcarlosrendon

Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed

{code:xml}
<entry>
<title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated>
</entry>
{code}

{code:xml}
<entry>
<title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated>
</entry>
{code}

They are for two different projects, but the ```<id>``` tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses.

I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue.

New: Original reporter https://github.com/mrcarlosrendon

Consider the following two entries found in the rssAll feed

{code:xml}
<entry>
<title>nctnhbaseworker/trunk #19 (stable)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/nctnhbaseworker/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:02:26Z</updated>
</entry>
{code}

{code:xml}
<entry>
<title>psclient/trunk #19 (1 test is still failing)</title>
<link type="text/html" href="http://irv-dev-pibld1:8080/job/psclient/branch/trunk/19/" rel="alternate"/>
<id>tag:hudson.dev.java.net,2015:trunk:19</id>
<published>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</published>
<updated>2015-12-22T00:04:24Z</updated>
</entry>
{code}

They are for two different projects, but the {{<id>}} tag for them is identical which breaks RSS feed readers that are expecting each entry to have a unique id as is required by the ATOM specification (http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc4287#section-4.2.6) that Jenkins uses.

I think adding the project name in addition to the branch name in the id field would solve the issue.

Daniel Beck made changes - 2015-12-31 16:24

Component/s	Original: cloudbees-folder-plugin [ 18137 ]
Component/s	Original: multi-branch-project-plugin [ 21127 ]
Labels	Original: multibranch nested

Matthew DeTullio made changes - 2016-07-02 01:03

Assignee

Original: Matthew DeTullio [ mjdetullio ]

Matthew DeTullio made changes - 2016-07-19 18:57

Summary

Original: RSS entry id's are not unique for Freestyle multi-branch project

New: RSS entry IDs are not unique for nested items (folders, multibranch projects, etc)

Matthew DeTullio made changes - 2016-07-19 19:02

Link

New: This issue is duplicated by ~~JENKINS-34767~~ [ ~~JENKINS-34767~~ ]

Matthew DeTullio made changes - 2016-07-19 19:02

Resolution		New: Fixed [ 1 ]
Status	Original: Open [ 1 ]	New: Resolved [ 5 ]

Assignee:: Unassigned

Reporter:: Matthew DeTullio

Votes:: 0 Vote for this issue

Watchers:: 1 Start watching this issue

Created:: 2015-12-30 23:38

Updated:: 2016-07-19 19:36

Resolved:: 2016-07-19 19:02

Jenkins

Details

Description

Attachments

Issue Links

Activity

People

Dates