Uploaded image for project: 'Jenkins'
  1. Jenkins
  2. JENKINS-39892

When the run fails with tests or another analysis then it should be more obvious

    • Icon: Task Task
    • Resolution: Unresolved
    • Icon: Major Major
    • blueocean-plugin
    • None
    • tasman, frank, christmas

      Problem

      When I upload a PR to GitHub and Jenkins responds with something bad and I click on details;
      In the traditional UI I get to the build page where I with a quick glance can most of the time directly see what is wrong, wether it's a test case that has failed or a checkstyle or findbugs violation etc.
      With BO I first get a blank page that load a bunch of stuff, compared to the traditional UI it takes forever, and during that load time I would have already found the culprit. And then I get a page that from my perspective shows me nothing except for a yellow color indicating an unstable build, but I sort of already knew that. And then I need to click around to find out what is wrong. While in the traditional build page I only need to click something to find out the details of why a particular thing is wrong.

      Possible solution

      • When we detect that tests that have failed (or another analysis that is the cause of a failed run) the log is not expanded and the "Issues detected" panel appears at the top of the screen.
      • Developer can click on the summary information in the issues detect and jump into analysis

          [JENKINS-39892] When the run fails with tests or another analysis then it should be more obvious

          James Dumay created issue -
          James Dumay made changes -
          Epic Link New: JENKINS-35755 [ 171716 ]
          James Dumay made changes -
          Description Original: *Problem*
          {quote}
          When I upload a PR to GitHub and Jenkins responds with something bad and I click on details;
          In the traditional UI I get to the build page where I with a quick glance can most of the time directly see what is wrong, wether it's a test case that has failed or a checkstyle or findbugs violation etc.
          With BO I first get a blank page that load a bunch of stuff, compared to the traditional UI it takes forever, and during that load time I would have already found the culprit. And then I get a page that from my perspective shows me nothing except for a yellow color indicating an unstable build, but I sort of already knew that. And then I need to click around to find out what is wrong. While in the traditional build page I only need to click something to find out the details of why a particular thing is wrong.
          {quote}
          New: *Problem*
          {quote}
          When I upload a PR to GitHub and Jenkins responds with something bad and I click on details;
          In the traditional UI I get to the build page where I with a quick glance can most of the time directly see what is wrong, wether it's a test case that has failed or a checkstyle or findbugs violation etc.
          With BO I first get a blank page that load a bunch of stuff, compared to the traditional UI it takes forever, and during that load time I would have already found the culprit. And then I get a page that from my perspective shows me nothing except for a yellow color indicating an unstable build, but I sort of already knew that. And then I need to click around to find out what is wrong. While in the traditional build page I only need to click something to find out the details of why a particular thing is wrong.
          {quote}

          *Possible solution*
          * When we detect that tests (or another analysis) is the cause of the failure the log is not expanded and the "Issues detected" panel appears at the top of the screen.
          * Developer can click on the summary information in the issues detect and jump into analysis
          James Dumay made changes -
          Sprint New: tasman [ 136 ]
          James Dumay made changes -
          Rank New: Ranked higher
          James Dumay made changes -
          Description Original: *Problem*
          {quote}
          When I upload a PR to GitHub and Jenkins responds with something bad and I click on details;
          In the traditional UI I get to the build page where I with a quick glance can most of the time directly see what is wrong, wether it's a test case that has failed or a checkstyle or findbugs violation etc.
          With BO I first get a blank page that load a bunch of stuff, compared to the traditional UI it takes forever, and during that load time I would have already found the culprit. And then I get a page that from my perspective shows me nothing except for a yellow color indicating an unstable build, but I sort of already knew that. And then I need to click around to find out what is wrong. While in the traditional build page I only need to click something to find out the details of why a particular thing is wrong.
          {quote}

          *Possible solution*
          * When we detect that tests (or another analysis) is the cause of the failure the log is not expanded and the "Issues detected" panel appears at the top of the screen.
          * Developer can click on the summary information in the issues detect and jump into analysis
          New: *Problem*
          {quote}
          When I upload a PR to GitHub and Jenkins responds with something bad and I click on details;
          In the traditional UI I get to the build page where I with a quick glance can most of the time directly see what is wrong, wether it's a test case that has failed or a checkstyle or findbugs violation etc.
          With BO I first get a blank page that load a bunch of stuff, compared to the traditional UI it takes forever, and during that load time I would have already found the culprit. And then I get a page that from my perspective shows me nothing except for a yellow color indicating an unstable build, but I sort of already knew that. And then I need to click around to find out what is wrong. While in the traditional build page I only need to click something to find out the details of why a particular thing is wrong.
          {quote}

          *Possible solution*
          * When we detect that tests that have failed (or another analysis that is the cause of a failed run) the log is not expanded and the "Issues detected" panel appears at the top of the screen.
          * Developer can click on the summary information in the issues detect and jump into analysis
          Michael Neale made changes -
          Priority Original: Minor [ 4 ] New: Major [ 3 ]
          Aydin Coskun made changes -
          Rank New: Ranked higher
          Brody Maclean made changes -
          Status Original: Open [ 1 ] New: In Progress [ 3 ]
          Brody Maclean made changes -
          Status Original: In Progress [ 3 ] New: In Review [ 10005 ]
          James Dumay made changes -
          Sprint Original: tasman [ 136 ] New: tasman, frank [ 136, 156 ]

            brody Brody Maclean
            jamesdumay James Dumay
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            5 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated: