-
Bug
-
Resolution: Fixed
-
Critical
-
-
tethys, pannonian
After installing BlueOcean beta, all links in the emails were changed to use BlueOcean URLs (which I find inconvenient, this should not be automatic in my opinion and I have been able to find a config option for this − happy to open a separate bug for this).
For the emails indicating a failure, the links are broken. Here are some examples:
- https://jenkins.company.com/blue/organizations/jenkins/jobA/detail/jobA/42/------------------------------------------/
- https://jenkins.acme.com/blue/organizations/jenkins/jobB/detail/jobB/773/------------------------------------------/
After uninstalling the BlueOcean plugins, the links are functional again:
- duplicates
-
-
- Closed
-
- is related to
-
JENKINS-41881 Automated test to cover fix for JENKINS-40224
-
- Resolved
-
- links to
[JENKINS-40224] Mailer links of failed jobs are broken with BlueOcean plugin, not redirecting properly
Jean-Frédéric
created issue -
| Component/s | New: blueocean-display-url-plugin [ 21827 ] |
| Description |
Original:
After installing BlueOcean beta, all links in the emails were changed to use BlueOcean URLs (which I find inconvenient, this should not be automatic in my opinion and I have been able to find a config option for this − happy to open a separate bug for this). For the emails indicating a failure, the links are broken. Here are some examples: * {{ https://jenkins.company.com/blue/organizations/jenkins/jobA/detail/jobA/42/------------------------------------------/ }} * {{ https://jenkins.acme.com/blue/organizations/jenkins/jobB/detail/jobB/773/------------------------------------------/ }} After uninstalling the BlueOcean plugins, the links are functional again: *{{ https://jenkins.acme.com/job/jobB/777/------------------------------------------/ }} which redirects properly to {{ https://jenkins.acme.com/job/jobB/777/ }} |
New:
After installing BlueOcean beta, all links in the emails were changed to use BlueOcean URLs (which I find inconvenient, this should not be automatic in my opinion and I have been able to find a config option for this − happy to open a separate bug for this). For the emails indicating a failure, the links are broken. Here are some examples: * {{ https://jenkins.company.com/blue/organizations/jenkins/jobA/detail/jobA/42/------------------------------------------/ }} * {{ https://jenkins.acme.com/blue/organizations/jenkins/jobB/detail/jobB/773/------------------------------------------/ }} After uninstalling the BlueOcean plugins, the links are functional again: * {{ https://jenkins.acme.com/job/jobB/777/------------------------------------------/ }} which redirects properly to {{ https://jenkins.acme.com/job/jobB/777/ }} |
| Description |
Original:
After installing BlueOcean beta, all links in the emails were changed to use BlueOcean URLs (which I find inconvenient, this should not be automatic in my opinion and I have been able to find a config option for this − happy to open a separate bug for this). For the emails indicating a failure, the links are broken. Here are some examples: * {{ https://jenkins.company.com/blue/organizations/jenkins/jobA/detail/jobA/42/------------------------------------------/ }} * {{ https://jenkins.acme.com/blue/organizations/jenkins/jobB/detail/jobB/773/------------------------------------------/ }} After uninstalling the BlueOcean plugins, the links are functional again: * {{ https://jenkins.acme.com/job/jobB/777/------------------------------------------/ }} which redirects properly to {{ https://jenkins.acme.com/job/jobB/777/ }} |
New:
After installing BlueOcean beta, all links in the emails were changed to use BlueOcean URLs (which I find inconvenient, this should not be automatic in my opinion and I have been able to find a config option for this − happy to open a separate bug for this). For the emails indicating a failure, the links are broken. Here are some examples: * {{https://jenkins.company.com/blue/organizations/jenkins/jobA/detail/jobA/42/------------------------------------------/}} * {{https://jenkins.acme.com/blue/organizations/jenkins/jobB/detail/jobB/773/------------------------------------------/}} After uninstalling the BlueOcean plugins, the links are functional again: * {{https://jenkins.acme.com/job/jobB/777/------------------------------------------/}} which redirects properly to {{https://jenkins.acme.com/job/jobB/777/}} |
jeanfred sorry you ran into a problem. What was broken about the links we generated? Did the page 404, etc?
We do have a configurable option in development for switching your links between Blue Ocean and Classic Jenkins. You can watch it on JENKINS-39580.
You mentioned that being switched to Blue Ocean is inconvenient. Is there something missing from Blue Ocean today that makes it hard for you to switch away from Classic?
| Assignee | New: James Dumay [ jamesdumay ] |
Jean-Frédéric
added a comment - Hi, thanks for answering to this issue !
I got around to try this again today (after submitting this issue I uninstalled all BlueOcean − had to reinstall them). I reinstalled everything but specifically not BlueOcean Display URL plugin. The problem is still there.
> What was broken about the links we generated? Did the page 404, etc?
Yes, the page does go in 404, with « Jenkins could not find the page you were looking for. Check the URL for errors or press the back button. » and the nice wave background (this must have been updated − I seem to recall it was simpler last week.
> We do have a configurable option in development for switching your links between Blue Ocean and Classic Jenkins. You can watch it on JENKINS-39580.
Thanks. I do think this is a necessary feature !
> You mentioned that being switched to Blue Ocean is inconvenient. Is there something missing from Blue Ocean today that makes it hard for you to switch away from Classic?
Generally speaking, I installed BlueOcean to get my team a sneak peak at what might be coming, so that they can give feedback on whether it is something they would want (generally the initial response is positive for now), however it is disruptive to be switched away straight away.
In particular, people have found finding jobs very frustrating. There is no search box as far as I can see, and the front page is quite useless since it is heavily paginated − we have more than 600 jobs, clicking « Read more » plenty of time does not work well. (We are not using Pipelines, and are not likely either to switch as we are very heavy users of Jenkins Job Builder).
Hope that helps !
Jean-Frédéric
added a comment - Hi, thanks for answering to this issue !
I got around to try this again today (after submitting this issue I uninstalled all BlueOcean − had to reinstall them). I reinstalled everything but specifically not BlueOcean Display URL plugin. The problem is still there.
> What was broken about the links we generated? Did the page 404, etc?
Yes, the page does go in 404, with « Jenkins could not find the page you were looking for. Check the URL for errors or press the back button. » and the nice wave background (this must have been updated − I seem to recall it was simpler last week.
> We do have a configurable option in development for switching your links between Blue Ocean and Classic Jenkins. You can watch it on JENKINS-39580 .
Thanks. I do think this is a necessary feature !
> You mentioned that being switched to Blue Ocean is inconvenient. Is there something missing from Blue Ocean today that makes it hard for you to switch away from Classic?
Generally speaking, I installed BlueOcean to get my team a sneak peak at what might be coming, so that they can give feedback on whether it is something they would want (generally the initial response is positive for now), however it is disruptive to be switched away straight away.
In particular, people have found finding jobs very frustrating. There is no search box as far as I can see, and the front page is quite useless since it is heavily paginated − we have more than 600 jobs, clicking « Read more » plenty of time does not work well. (We are not using Pipelines, and are not likely either to switch as we are very heavy users of Jenkins Job Builder).
Hope that helps ! jeanfred would the jobs you received 404 for happen to be Matrix projects or any other non-Pipeline or non-Freestyle job type? I suspect what you might be seeing is the problem described in JENKINS-40446 (which we have a fix for and is about to be released!)
> would the jobs you received 404 for happen to be Matrix projects or any other non-Pipeline or non-Freestyle job type?
No, these are all Freestyle jobs.
I think the root problem lies more with the Mailer plugin, which creates links like jenkins.acme.com/job/jobB/777/-------/. But these links are redirect properly with classic URLs, not with BlueOcean URLs.
Jean-Frédéric
added a comment - - edited > would the jobs you received 404 for happen to be Matrix projects or any other non-Pipeline or non-Freestyle job type?
No, these are all Freestyle jobs.
I think the root problem lies more with the Mailer plugin, which creates links like jenkins.acme.com/job/jobB/777/-------/ . But these links are redirect properly with classic URLs, not with BlueOcean URLs.
cc jamesdumay what is the plugin to disable to stop this? Is it the BlueOcean Display URL plugin?