Details
-
Type:
Task
-
Status: Closed (View Workflow)
-
Priority:
Critical
-
Resolution: Won't Do
-
Component/s: blueocean-pipeline-editor-plugin, scm-api-plugin
-
Labels:
-
Similar Issues:
-
Epic Link:
-
Sprint:frank, tethys, christmas
Description
Requirements
- Write natively to any branch of a Git repository hosted on Github
- Write to any branch of a Git repository
- Must maintain compatibility with Jenkins 2.7.1 and above
Desired user experience
- User experience is described in
JENKINS-41966 - Mockup: https://projects.invisionapp.com/share/Q2A110KM9#/screens/219088047
Attachments
Issue Links
- duplicates
-
JENKINS-39355 API improvements based on real-world implementation and usage
-
- Closed
-
- is blocking
-
JENKINS-36291
Pipeline Editor
-
- Open
-
- relates to
-
-
- Resolved
-
-
-
- Resolved
-
-
-
- Closed
-
Activity
| Field | Original Value | New Value |
|---|---|---|
| Epic Link | JENKINS-36291 [ 172300 ] |
| Link |
This issue relates to |
| Link |
This issue duplicates |
| Link |
This issue relates to |
| Component/s | scm-api-plugin [ 18054 ] |
| Description |
*Scope* * Github *Out of scope* * Git and Bitbucket support *Notes* For the [Blue Ocean Pipeline Editor|https://jenkins.io/blog/2016/09/19/blueocean-beta-declarative-pipeline-pipeline-editor/] we want to read the Jenkinsfile from the repository, let the user author it in the editor then commit it back to the repository. We need a new API and relevant implementations (Github and Bitbucket) that would allow Blue Ocean to read/write a file from the repository. [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
*Scope* * Github *Out of scope* * Git and Bitbucket support *Notes* For the [Blue Ocean Pipeline Editor|https://jenkins.io/blog/2016/09/19/blueocean-beta-declarative-pipeline-pipeline-editor/] we want to save the Jenkinsfile, let the user author it in the editor then commit it back to the repository. We need a new API and relevant implementations (Github and Bitbucket) that would allow Blue Ocean to read/write a file from the repository. [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
| Description |
*Scope* * Github *Out of scope* * Git and Bitbucket support *Notes* For the [Blue Ocean Pipeline Editor|https://jenkins.io/blog/2016/09/19/blueocean-beta-declarative-pipeline-pipeline-editor/] we want to save the Jenkinsfile, let the user author it in the editor then commit it back to the repository. We need a new API and relevant implementations (Github and Bitbucket) that would allow Blue Ocean to read/write a file from the repository. [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
*Scope* * Primary ** Github ** Github Enterprise * Secondary ** Bitbucket Server ** Bitbucket Cloud *Out of scope* * Git and support *Notes* For the [Blue Ocean Pipeline Editor|https://jenkins.io/blog/2016/09/19/blueocean-beta-declarative-pipeline-pipeline-editor/] we want to save the Jenkinsfile, let the user author it in the editor then commit it back to the repository. We need a new API and relevant implementations (Github and Bitbucket) that would allow Blue Ocean to read/write a file from the repository. [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
| Description |
*Scope* * Primary ** Github ** Github Enterprise * Secondary ** Bitbucket Server ** Bitbucket Cloud *Out of scope* * Git and support *Notes* For the [Blue Ocean Pipeline Editor|https://jenkins.io/blog/2016/09/19/blueocean-beta-declarative-pipeline-pipeline-editor/] we want to save the Jenkinsfile, let the user author it in the editor then commit it back to the repository. We need a new API and relevant implementations (Github and Bitbucket) that would allow Blue Ocean to read/write a file from the repository. [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
*Scope* * Primary ** Github ** Github Enterprise * Secondary ** Bitbucket Server ** Bitbucket Cloud *Out of scope* * Git and others support *Notes* For the [Blue Ocean Pipeline Editor|https://jenkins.io/blog/2016/09/19/blueocean-beta-declarative-pipeline-pipeline-editor/] we want to save the Jenkinsfile, let the user author it in the editor then commit it back to the repository. We need a new API and relevant implementations (Github and Bitbucket) that would allow Blue Ocean to read/write a file from the repository. [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
| Description |
*Scope* * Primary ** Github ** Github Enterprise * Secondary ** Bitbucket Server ** Bitbucket Cloud *Out of scope* * Git and others support *Notes* For the [Blue Ocean Pipeline Editor|https://jenkins.io/blog/2016/09/19/blueocean-beta-declarative-pipeline-pipeline-editor/] we want to save the Jenkinsfile, let the user author it in the editor then commit it back to the repository. We need a new API and relevant implementations (Github and Bitbucket) that would allow Blue Ocean to read/write a file from the repository. [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
*Scope* * Primary ** Github ** Github Enterprise * Secondary ** Bitbucket Server ** Bitbucket Cloud *Out of scope* * Git and others support *Notes* For the [Blue Ocean Pipeline Editor|https://jenkins.io/blog/2016/09/19/blueocean-beta-declarative-pipeline-pipeline-editor/], let the user author it in the editor then commit it back to the repository. We need a new API and relevant implementations (Github and Bitbucket) that would allow Blue Ocean to write a file from the repository. [ |
| Description |
*Scope* * Primary ** Github ** Github Enterprise * Secondary ** Bitbucket Server ** Bitbucket Cloud *Out of scope* * Git and others support *Notes* For the [Blue Ocean Pipeline Editor|https://jenkins.io/blog/2016/09/19/blueocean-beta-declarative-pipeline-pipeline-editor/], let the user author it in the editor then commit it back to the repository. We need a new API and relevant implementations (Github and Bitbucket) that would allow Blue Ocean to write a file from the repository. [ |
*Scope* * Primary ** Github ** Github Enterprise * Secondary ** Bitbucket Server ** Bitbucket Cloud *Out of scope* * Git and others support *Notes* For the [Blue Ocean Pipeline Editor|https://jenkins.io/blog/2016/09/19/blueocean-beta-declarative-pipeline-pipeline-editor/], let the user author it in the editor then commit it back to the repository. We need a new API and relevant implementations (Github and Bitbucket) that would allow Blue Ocean to write a file from the repository. |
| Description |
*Scope* * Primary ** Github ** Github Enterprise * Secondary ** Bitbucket Server ** Bitbucket Cloud *Out of scope* * Git and others support *Notes* For the [Blue Ocean Pipeline Editor|https://jenkins.io/blog/2016/09/19/blueocean-beta-declarative-pipeline-pipeline-editor/], let the user author it in the editor then commit it back to the repository. We need a new API and relevant implementations (Github and Bitbucket) that would allow Blue Ocean to write a file from the repository. |
*Scope* * Write natively to any branch of a Git repository hosted on Github * Write to any branch of a Git repository * Must not require a Jenkins core upgrade. Must maintain compatibility with Jenkins 2.7.1 and above. *Desired user experience* Mockup: https://projects.invisionapp.com/share/Q2A110KM9#/screens/219088047 |
| Description |
*Scope* * Write natively to any branch of a Git repository hosted on Github * Write to any branch of a Git repository * Must not require a Jenkins core upgrade. Must maintain compatibility with Jenkins 2.7.1 and above. *Desired user experience* Mockup: https://projects.invisionapp.com/share/Q2A110KM9#/screens/219088047 |
*Scope* * Write natively to any branch of a Git repository hosted on Github * Write to any branch of a Git repository * Must not require a Jenkins core upgrade. Must maintain compatibility with Jenkins 2.7.1 and above. *Desired user experience* Mockup: https://projects.invisionapp.com/share/Q2A110KM9#/screens/219088047 *Notes* [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
| Link | This issue is blocking JENKINS-36291 [ JENKINS-36291 ] |
| Description |
*Scope* * Write natively to any branch of a Git repository hosted on Github * Write to any branch of a Git repository * Must not require a Jenkins core upgrade. Must maintain compatibility with Jenkins 2.7.1 and above. *Desired user experience* Mockup: https://projects.invisionapp.com/share/Q2A110KM9#/screens/219088047 *Notes* [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
*Scope* * Write natively to any branch of a Git repository hosted on Github * Write to any branch of a Git repository * Must not require a Jenkins core upgrade. Must maintain compatibility with Jenkins 2.7.1 and above. *Desired user experience* * User experience is described in * Mockup: https://projects.invisionapp.com/share/Q2A110KM9#/screens/219088047 *Notes* [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
| Description |
*Scope* * Write natively to any branch of a Git repository hosted on Github * Write to any branch of a Git repository * Must not require a Jenkins core upgrade. Must maintain compatibility with Jenkins 2.7.1 and above. *Desired user experience* * User experience is described in * Mockup: https://projects.invisionapp.com/share/Q2A110KM9#/screens/219088047 *Notes* [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
*Requirements* * Write natively to any branch of a Git repository hosted on Github * Write to any branch of a Git repository * Must not require a Jenkins core upgrade. Must maintain compatibility with Jenkins 2.7.1 and above. *Desired user experience* * User experience is described in * Mockup: https://projects.invisionapp.com/share/Q2A110KM9#/screens/219088047 *Notes* [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
| Description |
*Requirements* * Write natively to any branch of a Git repository hosted on Github * Write to any branch of a Git repository * Must not require a Jenkins core upgrade. Must maintain compatibility with Jenkins 2.7.1 and above. *Desired user experience* * User experience is described in * Mockup: https://projects.invisionapp.com/share/Q2A110KM9#/screens/219088047 *Notes* [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
*Requirements* * Write natively to any branch of a Git repository hosted on Github * Write to any branch of a Git repository * Must maintain compatibility with Jenkins 2.7.1 and above *Desired user experience* * User experience is described in * Mockup: https://projects.invisionapp.com/share/Q2A110KM9#/screens/219088047 *Notes* [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
| Sprint | frank, tethys, christmas, post-release [ 156, 161, 176, 181 ] | frank, tethys, christmas [ 156, 161, 176 ] |
| Link |
This issue relates to |
This was cloned from JENKINS-39703 Jesse Glick and the comment is from you referring to the Read API. I split this off to track the write API separately.
| Description |
*Requirements* * Write natively to any branch of a Git repository hosted on Github * Write to any branch of a Git repository * Must maintain compatibility with Jenkins 2.7.1 and above *Desired user experience* * User experience is described in * Mockup: https://projects.invisionapp.com/share/Q2A110KM9#/screens/219088047 *Notes* [~jglick] said there is beginnings of this in the scm-api but no implementations. |
*Requirements* * Write natively to any branch of a Git repository hosted on Github * Write to any branch of a Git repository * Must maintain compatibility with Jenkins 2.7.1 and above *Desired user experience* * User experience is described in * Mockup: https://projects.invisionapp.com/share/Q2A110KM9#/screens/219088047 |
| Sprint | frank, tethys, christmas [ 156, 161, 176 ] | frank, tethys, christmas, 1.1 [ 156, 161, 176, 251 ] |
| Rank | Ranked lower |
| Rank | Ranked higher |
| Priority | Major [ 3 ] | Critical [ 2 ] |
| Rank | Ranked higher |
| Rank | Ranked higher |
As noted in JENKINS-39703, SCMFile may need to add some methods to define some new abstract type SCMFileContent which has contentAsBytes etc. but also a replace method—since GitHub does not let you overwrite a file without specifying what you are overwriting (presumably to avoid data loss with non-fast-forward merges).
| Rank | Ranked higher |
| Rank | Ranked lower |
| Sprint | frank, tethys, christmas, Blue Ocean up next [ 156, 161, 176, 251 ] | frank, tethys, christmas [ 156, 161, 176 ] |
| Rank | Ranked lower |
We've a method around this now.
| Resolution | Won't Do [ 10001 ] | |
| Status | Open [ 1 ] | Resolved [ 5 ] |
| Status | Resolved [ 5 ] | Closed [ 6 ] |
No, there has never been any proposed API to write files. Sounds like a battle which should not be picked—just provide a downloadable file and ask people to commit it when ready.