[JENKINS-51035] Regression: Job DSL `folder('existing-folder')` creation destroys any views in that folder

Type: Bug
Resolution: Duplicate
Priority: Major
Component/s: job-dsl-plugin
Labels:
None

Similar Issues:
Powered by SuggestiMate

Show

This is a regression observed between Jenkins LTS 2.89.4 and LTS 2.107.2.

The version of the Job DSL plugin (1.69) is unchanged.

To reproduce:

1. Run the following Job DSL to create a folder and some sample views within that folder.

folder('/dir') {
  displayName('dir')
}
buildMonitorView('/dir/Test BMV') {
  jobs { regex('.*') }
}
listView('/dir/Test LV') {
  jobs { regex(".*") }
}

2. Run the following Job DSL script on its own.

folder('/dir') {
  displayName('dir')
}

Before the upgrade to Jenkins 2.107.2, this worked fine. Following the upgrade, step 2 destroys the views that were created in step 1.

duplicates

JENKINS-31308 Creating folder removes existing views within that

Open

Oliver Lockwood created issue - 2018-04-27 06:50

Oliver Lockwood made changes - 2018-04-27 07:49

Issue Type

Original: Improvement [ 4 ]

New: Bug [ 1 ]

Oliver Lockwood made changes - 2018-04-27 09:04

Description

Original: This is a regression observed between Jenkins LTS 2.89.4 and LTS 2.107.2.

The version of the Job DSL plugin (1.69) is unchanged.

To reproduce:
# Run the following Job DSL to create a folder and some sample views within that folder.
{{folder('/dir') \{}}
{{ displayName('dir')}}
{{}}}
{{buildMonitorView('/dir/Test BMV') \{}}
{{ jobs \{ regex('.*') }}}
{{}}}
{{listView('/dir/Test LV') \{}}
{{ jobs \{ regex(".*") }}}
{{}}}
# Run the following Job DSL script on its own.
{{folder('/dir') \{}}
{{ displayName('dir')}}
{{}}}

Before the upgrade to Jenkins 2.107.2, this worked fine. Following the upgrade, step 2 destroys the views that were created in step 1.

New: This is a regression observed between Jenkins LTS 2.89.4 and LTS 2.107.2.

The version of the Job DSL plugin (1.69) is unchanged.

To reproduce:
# Run the following Job DSL to create a folder and some sample views within that folder.
{{}}
{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
   displayName('dir')
}
buildMonitorView('/dir/Test BMV') {
   jobs { regex('.*') }
}
listView('/dir/Test LV') {
   jobs { regex(".*") }
}{noformat}
{{}}
# Run the following Job DSL script on its own.
{{}}
{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
   displayName('dir')
}{noformat}
{{}}

Before the upgrade to Jenkins 2.107.2, this worked fine. Following the upgrade, step 2 destroys the views that were created in step 1.

Oliver Lockwood made changes - 2018-04-27 09:04

Description

Original: This is a regression observed between Jenkins LTS 2.89.4 and LTS 2.107.2.

The version of the Job DSL plugin (1.69) is unchanged.

To reproduce:
# Run the following Job DSL to create a folder and some sample views within that folder.
{{}}
{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
   displayName('dir')
}
buildMonitorView('/dir/Test BMV') {
   jobs { regex('.*') }
}
listView('/dir/Test LV') {
   jobs { regex(".*") }
}{noformat}
{{}}
# Run the following Job DSL script on its own.
{{}}
{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
   displayName('dir')
}{noformat}
{{}}

Before the upgrade to Jenkins 2.107.2, this worked fine. Following the upgrade, step 2 destroys the views that were created in step 1.

New: This is a regression observed between Jenkins LTS 2.89.4 and LTS 2.107.2.

The version of the Job DSL plugin (1.69) is unchanged.

To reproduce:
# Run the following Job DSL to create a folder and some sample views within that folder.

{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
   displayName('dir')
}
buildMonitorView('/dir/Test BMV') {
   jobs { regex('.*') }
}
listView('/dir/Test LV') {
   jobs { regex(".*") }
}{noformat}

# Run the following Job DSL script on its own.

{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
   displayName('dir')
}{noformat}

Before the upgrade to Jenkins 2.107.2, this worked fine. Following the upgrade, step 2 destroys the views that were created in step 1.

Oliver Lockwood made changes - 2018-04-27 09:04

Description

Original: This is a regression observed between Jenkins LTS 2.89.4 and LTS 2.107.2.

The version of the Job DSL plugin (1.69) is unchanged.

To reproduce:
# Run the following Job DSL to create a folder and some sample views within that folder.

{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
   displayName('dir')
}
buildMonitorView('/dir/Test BMV') {
   jobs { regex('.*') }
}
listView('/dir/Test LV') {
   jobs { regex(".*") }
}{noformat}

# Run the following Job DSL script on its own.

{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
   displayName('dir')
}{noformat}

Before the upgrade to Jenkins 2.107.2, this worked fine. Following the upgrade, step 2 destroys the views that were created in step 1.

New: This is a regression observed between Jenkins LTS 2.89.4 and LTS 2.107.2.

The version of the Job DSL plugin (1.69) is unchanged.

To reproduce:

*1.* Run the following Job DSL to create a folder and some sample views within that folder.
{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
   displayName('dir')
}
buildMonitorView('/dir/Test BMV') {
   jobs { regex('.*') }
}
listView('/dir/Test LV') {
   jobs { regex(".*") }
}{noformat}
*2.* Run the following Job DSL script on its own.
{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
   displayName('dir')
}{noformat}

Before the upgrade to Jenkins 2.107.2, this worked fine. Following the upgrade, step 2 destroys the views that were created in step 1.

Oliver Lockwood made changes - 2018-04-27 09:05

Description

Original: This is a regression observed between Jenkins LTS 2.89.4 and LTS 2.107.2.

The version of the Job DSL plugin (1.69) is unchanged.

To reproduce:

*1.* Run the following Job DSL to create a folder and some sample views within that folder.
{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
   displayName('dir')
}
buildMonitorView('/dir/Test BMV') {
   jobs { regex('.*') }
}
listView('/dir/Test LV') {
   jobs { regex(".*") }
}{noformat}
*2.* Run the following Job DSL script on its own.
{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
   displayName('dir')
}{noformat}

Before the upgrade to Jenkins 2.107.2, this worked fine. Following the upgrade, step 2 destroys the views that were created in step 1.

New: This is a regression observed between Jenkins LTS 2.89.4 and LTS 2.107.2.

The version of the Job DSL plugin (1.69) is unchanged.

To reproduce:

*1.* Run the following Job DSL to create a folder and some sample views within that folder.
{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
displayName('dir')
}
buildMonitorView('/dir/Test BMV') {
jobs { regex('.*') }
}
listView('/dir/Test LV') {
jobs { regex(".*") }
}{noformat}
*2.* Run the following Job DSL script on its own.
{noformat}
folder('/dir') {
displayName('dir')
}{noformat}

Before the upgrade to Jenkins 2.107.2, this worked fine. Following the upgrade, step 2 destroys the views that were created in step 1.

Daniel Spilker made changes - 2018-06-20 22:03

Link

New: This issue duplicates JENKINS-31308 [ JENKINS-31308 ]

Daniel Spilker made changes - 2018-06-20 22:03

Resolution		New: Duplicate [ 3 ]
Status	Original: Open [ 1 ]	New: Resolved [ 5 ]

Daniel Spilker made changes - 2018-07-03 20:23

Status

Original: Resolved [ 5 ]

New: Closed [ 6 ]

Assignee:: Daniel Spilker

Reporter:: Oliver Lockwood

Votes:: 1 Vote for this issue

Watchers:: 2 Start watching this issue

Created:: 2018-04-27 06:50

Updated:: 2018-07-03 20:23

Resolved:: 2018-06-20 22:03

Jenkins

Details

Description

Attachments

Issue Links

Activity

People

Dates