• Type: Bug
• Resolution: Not A Defect
• Priority: Minor
• Component/s: influxdb-plugin
• Labels:

  None

[JENKINS-67728] build_result/oridinal doesn't seem to be reliable

Richard Cole created issue - 2022-02-03 10:20

Richard Cole made changes - 2022-02-03 10:28

Description

Original: I'm finding this metric to be slightly unreliable.  It seems to flip between SUCCESS and ?.  For the oridinal I seem to only ever get 0 or 5. I'm not sure 100% sure, but the unreliable data seems to come from pipeline builds, running something from a cmd script for example seems ok.

New: I'm finding this metric to be slightly unreliable.  It seems to flip between SUCCESS and ?.  For the oridinal I seem to only ever get 0 or 5. I'm not sure 100% sure, but the unreliable data seems to come from pipeline builds, running something from a cmd script for example seems ok. Key part of the code appears to be: {code:java} // Build is not finished when running with pipelines. Set build status as unknown and ordinal // as something not predefined String result; int ordinal; Result buildResult = build.getResult(); if (buildResult == null) {    result = "?";    ordinal = 5; } else {    result = buildResult.toString();    ordinal = buildResult.ordinal; } {code} Inside jenkinsci.plugins.influxdb.generators.JenkinsBasePointGenerator

Richard Cole made changes - 2022-02-03 10:29

Description

Original: I'm finding this metric to be slightly unreliable.  It seems to flip between SUCCESS and ?.  For the oridinal I seem to only ever get 0 or 5. I'm not sure 100% sure, but the unreliable data seems to come from pipeline builds, running something from a cmd script for example seems ok. Key part of the code appears to be: {code:java} // Build is not finished when running with pipelines. Set build status as unknown and ordinal // as something not predefined String result; int ordinal; Result buildResult = build.getResult(); if (buildResult == null) {    result = "?";    ordinal = 5; } else {    result = buildResult.toString();    ordinal = buildResult.ordinal; } {code} Inside jenkinsci.plugins.influxdb.generators.JenkinsBasePointGenerator

New: I'm finding this metric to be slightly unreliable.  It seems to flip between SUCCESS and ?.  For the oridinal I seem to only ever get 0 or 5. I'm not sure 100% sure, but the unreliable data seems to come from pipeline builds, running something from a cmd script for example seems ok. Key part of the code appears to be: {code:java} // Build is not finished when running with pipelines. Set build status as unknown and ordinal // as something not predefined String result; int ordinal; Result buildResult = build.getResult(); if (buildResult == null) {    result = "?";    ordinal = 5; } else {    result = buildResult.toString();    ordinal = buildResult.ordinal; } {code} Inside jenkinsci.plugins.influxdb.generators.JenkinsBasePointGenerator. Does it mean we cannot get reliable metrics on a pipeline based job?

Aleksi Simell made changes - 2022-07-26 12:34

Resolution		New: Not A Defect [ 7 ]
Status	Original: Open [ 1 ]	New: Closed [ 6 ]