First ongoing action: we have gathered support bundles, and submitted them for analysis to the CloudBees Support team.
First outcome after GC analysis is https://github.com/jenkins-infra/jenkins-infra/pull/1375

This is NOT deemed as the fix to rule them all. But it is definitely a first step to fix various unideal or wrong configurations to progressively narrow down problems.

I've been looking at the support bundles;

So the thread dumps are indicating what people seems to say, it is mostly filled with metrics threads.

The Jenkins log has a lot of failing to provision ACi agents:

WARNING c.m.j.c.aci.AciCloud$1#call: AciCloud: Provision agent aci-maven-4mwg0 failed: Status code 409, {"error":{"code":"DeploymentQuotaExceeded","message":"Creating the deployment 'aci-maven-h6n6bs6x' would exceed the quota of '800'. The current deployment count is '800', please delete some deployments before creating a new one. Please see https://aka.ms/arm-debug for usage details."}}

And

2019-10-18 10:51:29.415+0000 [id=1021880] WARNING c.m.j.c.aci.AciCloud#canProvision: Cannot provision: template for label maven-11-windows is not available now, because it failed to provision last time.

What does a deployment count of 800 means? That we had 800 instances running!?

I also see a bunch of

2019-10-18 10:44:12.601+0000 [id=1018868] INFO c.m.j.c.aci.AciCleanTask#cleanDeployments: AzureAciCleanUpTask: cleanDeployments: Checking deployment aci-maven-11-zhdwvcqv
2019-10-18 10:44:12.769+0000 [id=1018868] INFO c.m.j.c.aci.AciCleanTask#cleanDeployments: AzureAciCleanUpTask: cleanDeployments: Deployment not found, skipping

Are we leaking deployments in the Azure cloud plugin?

I’ve been monitoring https://ci.jenkins.io for the past two days since Arnaud restarted it, and besides a bunch of agents that can’t be connected to it seems to have been handling itself fine. Though it hasn’t been much going on in the instance, a few plugin PR builds and a few core PR builds.

Do we have any historical data on how long the instance has survived between restarts in the past?

I'm wondering if there is another leak besides metrics and if so how long until it should manifest again. Because as of now it looks OK though the load hasn't been that high these last two days.

What does a deployment count of 800 means? That we had 800 instances running!?

IIRC this happened after a sequence of several restarts in an afternoon, indicating obsolete instance do not get cleaned up properly, or in a timely manner, after Jenkins restart. Let each powercycle use up another 150 or so instances…

I just idly checked the /threadDump on ci.j.io

SupportPlugin periodic bundle generator: writing support_2019-11-01_10.21.58.zip since Fri Nov 01 10:21:58 UTC 2019

As of…

Page generated: Nov 1, 2019, 10:46:47 AM

Collecting months old log files can easily be considered a bug in support-core, as they're probably useless anyway.

Moved old GC logs into the subdirectory gc/ in JENKINS_HOME. Baptiste Mathus wanted the plugin re-enabled, so he gets to fix the java args to place GC logs there directly

Just copying my suggestion in IRC here:

• We keep this EPIC for the immediate ci.jenkins.io stabilization activities after the last massive outage in late October
• We use the "ci.jenkins.io" component and "maintenability", "stability", "ux" labels in order to braindump ideas about improving ci.jenkins.io in longer term so that we spend less time on firefighting. If there is a consensus about it, I will create dashboards to track it

WDYT Baptiste Mathus Olblak?