Uploaded image for project: 'Jenkins'
  1. Jenkins
  2. JENKINS-26136

Claim for failed test disappears when a new build finishes

XMLWordPrintable

      If I claim a failed test in the latest build (say #128), this claim gets lost as soon as the next build (say #129) finishes.

      The expected behaviour is, that the claim remains (in #128) and - if the "Sticky" checkbox was selected - a claim gets created for the same test in the new build (#129), if it still fails.

      I'm willing to help with the fix because this would be a very useful feature for our team if it worked as expected.

          [JENKINS-26136] Claim for failed test disappears when a new build finishes

          LuFrija added a comment -

          Apparently we are also affected by this problem, even though we are currently using a newer version of the plugin (2.13) and Jenkins (2.19.4). The claim gets lost in the subsequent build even if the option "sticky" is selected. The problem does not show up in every job, but rather only in some.

          We are using the claim plugin inside scripted pipeline.

          LuFrija added a comment - Apparently we are also affected by this problem, even though we are currently using a newer version of the plugin (2.13) and Jenkins (2.19.4). The claim gets lost in the subsequent build even if the option "sticky" is selected. The problem does not show up in every job, but rather only in some. We are using the claim plugin inside scripted pipeline.

          Arnaud TAMAILLON added a comment -

          Hi rocco,

          Would you be able to provide some details on the use case, and maybe a reproducer ?
          Are claims lost when encountering a build where tests are not run for example (due to compile failure ?), or some other pattern ?

          Arnaud TAMAILLON added a comment - Hi rocco , Would you be able to provide some details on the use case, and maybe a reproducer ? Are claims lost when encountering a build where tests are not run for example (due to compile failure ?), or some other pattern ?

          LuFrija added a comment -

          hi greybird , we actually got hit by

          https://issues.jenkins-ci.org/browse/JENKINS-30413

          So basically we just made sure not to have tests with same name and the issue was solved. So my case ha nothing to do with the claim plugin itself.

          LuFrija added a comment - hi greybird , we actually got hit by https://issues.jenkins-ci.org/browse/JENKINS-30413 So basically we just made sure not to have tests with same name and the issue was solved. So my case ha nothing to do with the claim plugin itself.

          Arnaud TAMAILLON added a comment -

          Hi rocco,

          Thanks for your answer!
          I will close this issue then.

          Arnaud

          Arnaud TAMAILLON added a comment - Hi rocco , Thanks for your answer! I will close this issue then. Arnaud

            greybird Arnaud TAMAILLON
            msa Michael Schaufelberger
            Votes:
            3 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            7 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: