When project configuration is changed, Promoted Builds Plugin continues to use "old" configuration data

I've been experimenting with different configurations for promoting builds, now when the promotion happens I'm getting no less than 3 stars applied alongside the build name.
Two of them should not be there for two reasons
(1) because they are based on configuration information that is no longer part of the job configuration, it should have been overwritten;
(2) They actually fail according to their own status!

Please see attached screenshots.