-
Bug
-
Resolution: Fixed
-
Major
-
None
-
Win7, approx 100 Projects, incremental backups weekdays, full backup Sunday
One of my fellow workers claimed thinBackup was taking Jenkins down, sure enough I found that the case myself this morning.
Shutdown could not be cancelled (it would go down, but immediately be reasserted). ThinBackup had some messages about waiting for quiet mode, but there also seemed to be an exception related to cancelling shutdown, scanning with my non-Java eye, it wasn't clear it the exception was thinBackup related or not.
End of Jenkins log provided
- duplicates
-
-
- Resolved
-
[JENKINS-13239] ThinBackup puts Jenkins into Shutdown (repeatedly) . . . revisited
Thomas Fürer
added a comment - Integrated in 
thinBackup #33
JENKINS-13239: provide a option to skip the wait for idle condition (untested) (Revision 40359)
Result = SUCCESS
alienllama : 40359
Files :
- /trunk/hudson/plugins/thinBackup/src/main/java/org/jvnet/hudson/plugins/thinbackup/ThinBackupPeriodicWork.java
- /trunk/hudson/plugins/thinBackup/src/main/java/org/jvnet/hudson/plugins/thinbackup/ThinBackupPluginImpl.java
- /trunk/hudson/plugins/thinBackup/src/main/resources/org/jvnet/hudson/plugins/thinbackup/ThinBackupMgmtLink/backupsettings.jelly
- /trunk/hudson/plugins/thinBackup/src/main/webapp/help/help-waitForIdle.html
Thomas Fürer
added a comment - Integrated in thinBackup #33
JENKINS-13239 : provide a option to skip the wait for idle condition (untested) (Revision 40359)
Result = SUCCESS
alienllama : 40359
Files :
/trunk/hudson/plugins/thinBackup/src/main/java/org/jvnet/hudson/plugins/thinbackup/ThinBackupPeriodicWork.java
/trunk/hudson/plugins/thinBackup/src/main/java/org/jvnet/hudson/plugins/thinbackup/ThinBackupPluginImpl.java
/trunk/hudson/plugins/thinBackup/src/main/resources/org/jvnet/hudson/plugins/thinbackup/ThinBackupMgmtLink/backupsettings.jelly
/trunk/hudson/plugins/thinBackup/src/main/webapp/help/help-waitForIdle.html
Gary Sorhaindo
added a comment - Hi,
I am also continuing to see this issue. I know it was apparently resolved with version 1.5 but I have an installation running Thin Backup version 1.6 (Jenkins version 1.460) and an installation running Thin Backup version 1.5 (Jenkins version 1.427) and am periodically seeing the issue. The red bar stating that 'Jenkins is going to be shutdown' still appears.
If I choose to skip the wait for idle condition, will this result in potentially corrupted backups?
Further environmental information can be provided on request.
Many thanks
Gary
Gary Sorhaindo
added a comment - Hi,
I am also continuing to see this issue. I know it was apparently resolved with version 1.5 but I have an installation running Thin Backup version 1.6 (Jenkins version 1.460) and an installation running Thin Backup version 1.5 (Jenkins version 1.427) and am periodically seeing the issue. The red bar stating that 'Jenkins is going to be shutdown' still appears.
If I choose to skip the wait for idle condition, will this result in potentially corrupted backups?
Further environmental information can be provided on request.
Many thanks
Gary Thomas Fürer
added a comment - hi Gary,
this the expected behavior of the current implementation. currently you cannot fall in a situation where a job modifies data while the backup is running, because the backup is only done in the quiet mode.
maybe i should work on a solution where a bring up another text message which midge be abortable, which means no backup of you abort the quite mode. I need to research how it can be done...
thomas
Thomas Fürer
added a comment - hi Gary,
this the expected behavior of the current implementation. currently you cannot fall in a situation where a job modifies data while the backup is running, because the backup is only done in the quiet mode.
maybe i should work on a solution where a bring up another text message which midge be abortable, which means no backup of you abort the quite mode. I need to research how it can be done...
thomas Thomas Fürer
added a comment - included in version 1.6
after testing it on the productive system I set it to resolved
Thomas Fürer
added a comment - included in version 1.6
after testing it on the productive system I set it to resolved Gary Sorhaindo
added a comment - Many thanks for your prompt response Thomas. And I agree with what you say - a different message, which is abortable would be great, if this is possible.
But in the mean time - you said that "you cannot fall in a situation where a job modifies data while the backup is running".
With regard to that statement, what happens if I de-select the "Wait until Jenkins/Hudson is idle to perform a backup" option that was introduced in Thin backup 1.6? When using this option, do I risk making corrupt backups?
Thanks in advance.
Gary
Gary Sorhaindo
added a comment - Many thanks for your prompt response Thomas. And I agree with what you say - a different message, which is abortable would be great, if this is possible.
But in the mean time - you said that "you cannot fall in a situation where a job modifies data while the backup is running".
With regard to that statement, what happens if I de-select the "Wait until Jenkins/Hudson is idle to perform a backup" option that was introduced in Thin backup 1.6? When using this option, do I risk making corrupt backups?
Thanks in advance.
Gary Code changed in jenkins
User: alienllama
Path:
src/main/java/org/jvnet/hudson/plugins/thinbackup/ThinBackupPeriodicWork.java
src/main/java/org/jvnet/hudson/plugins/thinbackup/ThinBackupPluginImpl.java
src/main/resources/org/jvnet/hudson/plugins/thinbackup/ThinBackupMgmtLink/backupsettings.jelly
src/main/webapp/help/help-waitForIdle.html
http://jenkins-ci.org/commit/thin-backup-plugin/5324059e1f9100af23612ecba1049a9384a032e5
Log:
JENKINS-13239: provide a option to skip the wait for idle condition (untested)
git-svn-id: https://svn.jenkins-ci.org/trunk/hudson/plugins/thinBackup@40359 71c3de6d-444a-0410-be80-ed276b4c234a
Linking this issue to
JENKINS-9117. Can you please confirm this issue is (or is not) resolved byJENKINS-9117? (Upgrade to plugin version 1.5.