Uploaded image for project: 'Jenkins'
  1. Jenkins
  2. JENKINS-14773

Warnings plugin has renumbered internally - breaks builds!

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Duplicate
    • Icon: Major Major
    • warnings-plugin
    • None
    • Jenkins 1.476, warnings 4.13

      We have some jobs where we fail builds if there are new warnings. After upgrading to warnings-4.13, it appears that the "MSBuild" parser has changed its internal number from 25 to 27, causing all warnings to be counted as New, thus failing every single build since the upgrade.
      I think the renumbering is to blame because I can see in my logs that a request for a file called "compiler-27-warnings.xml" fails. Such a file is indeed present in the new builds, whereas the old builds instead have a file called "compiler-25-warnings.xml". I also have files called "compiler-1-warnings.xml" (dynamic parser) and "compiler-warnings.xml" (all parsers combined).
      So it looks to me that MSBuild has changed value (an enum, perhaps?). This breaks all our builds. We can probably save them by re-configuring to not check for new warnings, build once, and then re-enable the check, but I don't really want to do that every time new parsers are added to the plugin!
      So may I suggest that it be written explicitly in the plugin code that existing parsers under no circumstances should change number?
      Or that the filenames be based on something a little more "predictable" than an enum? Or perhaps the file with all warnings could be used instead?

          [JENKINS-14773] Warnings plugin has renumbered internally - breaks builds!

          torbent added a comment -

          Also (but I don't know if it's the same root cause), for the dynamic parser it reports (e.g.) 48 new warnings, but when following the link to those new warnings, I get an empty list.
          There are no messages in my Jenkins log for this.

          torbent added a comment - Also (but I don't know if it's the same root cause), for the dynamic parser it reports (e.g.) 48 new warnings, but when following the link to those new warnings, I get an empty list. There are no messages in my Jenkins log for this.

          torbent added a comment -

          So, even after the "don't check - check again" cycle and a couple of successful builds, the plugin behaved badly (counting wildly) so I reverted to the previous version, which in our case turned out to be 4.6.
          It still doesn't count just right, but I'll make a new issue for that.

          torbent added a comment - So, even after the "don't check - check again" cycle and a couple of successful builds, the plugin behaved badly (counting wildly) so I reverted to the previous version, which in our case turned out to be 4.6. It still doesn't count just right, but I'll make a new issue for that.

          torbent added a comment -

          Yes, duplicate

          torbent added a comment - Yes, duplicate

            drulli Ulli Hafner
            torbent torbent
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            1 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: