Details
-
Type:
Bug
-
Status: Resolved (View Workflow)
-
Priority:
Major
-
Resolution: Duplicate
-
Component/s: matrix-auth-plugin
-
Labels:None
-
Similar Issues:
Description
If cancel privilege not granted also,users able to cancel building job.
Attachments
Issue Links
- is related to
-
-
- Resolved
-
Activity
Throwing in my 2 cents here.
Our automation jobs don't currently handle cancellation well. Currently a proper solution won't be made for the short or medium term, so I've tried to disable cancel permissions for all but 1 group who have been trained to perform all required cleanup after cancelling a job.
Your plugin does indeed have a "Cancel" permission under the "Jobs" group. Not granting that permission seems to remove the ability to cancel jobs from the queue and slave sidebars on Jenkins, but alternative cancel buttons can still be found when clicking into the jobs themselves.
So it looks like you're restricting the cancellation of jobs, but not in all places.
Brent Goodacre
added a comment - - edited Throwing in my 2 cents here.
Our automation jobs don't currently handle cancellation well. Currently a proper solution won't be made for the short or medium term, so I've tried to disable cancel permissions for all but 1 group who have been trained to perform all required cleanup after cancelling a job.
Your plugin does indeed have a "Cancel" permission under the "Jobs" group. Not granting that permission seems to remove the ability to cancel jobs from the queue and slave sidebars on Jenkins, but alternative cancel buttons can still be found when clicking into the jobs themselves.
So it looks like you're restricting the cancellation of jobs, but not in all places. Any news on this topic?
I need to prevent special jobs from being canceled. A cancel shall not be possible even for the user which has started the job. Only the administrator shall have the permission to do that.
Especially using the ClearCase plugin as SCM source will damage the ClearCase view irreparable if the build is canceled during SCM step.
Nico Falk
added a comment - Any news on this topic?
I need to prevent special jobs from being canceled. A cancel shall not be possible even for the user which has started the job. Only the administrator shall have the permission to do that.
Especially using the ClearCase plugin as SCM source will damage the ClearCase view irreparable if the build is canceled during SCM step. The UI issue duplicates JENKINS-32506.
The underlying unexpected implication issue is tracked as JENKINS-14713.
What is the current status of this issue?
I think it is in general a good idea that the user which triggers a build could cancel his own job but are not allowed to cancel jobs from other users expect the user has the "cancel" flag or is an admin