Details
-
Type:
Bug
-
Status: Resolved (View Workflow)
-
Priority:
Major
-
Resolution: Cannot Reproduce
-
Component/s: prioritysorter-plugin, throttle-concurrent-builds-plugin
-
Labels:
-
Similar Issues:
Description
I have a need to use both the Throttle Concurrent Builds plugin and the Priority Sorter plugin. Say I have three jobs A, B, and C that use a throttle that allows only one concurrent execution on the master. They are all using the default priority (100). If I queue up A, then B and C, A starts running and B and C wait, throttled as they should be. But as soon as A completes, both B and C start, simultaneously. The throttle is being ignored. This worked until the Priority Sorter plugin was installed.
I believe this issue is different from Jenkins 15090, I'm not concerned with SCM polling issues, or in this example, in the order of execution. I just need Priority Sorter to not meddle with the throttles.
I am using:
Jenkins 1.470
Throttle Concurrent Builds Plugin 1.6
Priority Sorter Plugin 1.3
Attachments
Activity
There's no explicit conflicts between plugins.
Laura, could you re-test the issue with newest versions of both plugins?
I suspect that your issue have been caused by concurrency issues, but there are too many changes in both plugins.
I retested with (old) versions as above and was not able to reproduce. I thought I did the same a few weeks back and tried to close this issue as non-reproducible, but I obviously didn't succeed.
Upgrading versions is somewhat problematic here - long story. But I think it appropriate to close this as non-reproducible. Hope this helps.
Laura Neff
added a comment - I retested with (old) versions as above and was not able to reproduce. I thought I did the same a few weeks back and tried to close this issue as non-reproducible, but I obviously didn't succeed.
Upgrading versions is somewhat problematic here - long story. But I think it appropriate to close this as non-reproducible. Hope this helps. Thanks for the update.
Priority-sorter.2.x still has many issue, but I'm sure that Magnus will fix them at some point.
Regarding this issue, I cannot reproduce it as well. I'll mark it as "resolved/cannot reproduce". Please let me know if you experience any compatibility issues in future.
Removed the obsolete assignee