Uploaded image for project: 'Jenkins'
  1. Jenkins
  2. JENKINS-19986

Throttle Concurrent Builds plugin doesn't appear to work

XMLWordPrintable

    • Icon: Bug Bug
    • Resolution: Duplicate
    • Icon: Major Major
    • throttle-concurrent-builds-plugin
    • None
    • Jenkins 1.509.2, Throttle Concurrent Builds 1.8

      I just installed this today to try and avoid some issues I have with locks & latches. I have some multi-configuration jobs. I want to allow multiple jobs to run at the same time, but only 1 job of a given category to run per node. This sounds exactly like what the plugin was written for. So I went into my configuration and created a category and set Maximum Total Concurrent Builds to 0 and Maximum Concurrent Builds Per Node to 1. I then went to all of my jobs and assigned them to this category and checked the radio button for throttle as part of one or more categories.

      I then manually started two jobs from the same category to see if one waited for the other. It didn't work. Both jobs started on the same node. I also tried settings Maximum Concurrent Builds Per Node in the job itself to 1 and that didn't help either.

      What am I missing about this configuration?

          [JENKINS-19986] Throttle Concurrent Builds plugin doesn't appear to work

          jpschewe created issue -

          Yves Hwang added a comment -

          I can confirm that builds were successful for us until early this week where we upgraded to Jenkins.
          Throttle 1.8 and Jenkins 1.536

          Yves Hwang added a comment - I can confirm that builds were successful for us until early this week where we upgraded to Jenkins. Throttle 1.8 and Jenkins 1.536
          Marcel Beister made changes -
          Link New: This issue is related to JENKINS-20211 [ JENKINS-20211 ]

          Marcel Beister added a comment - - edited

          Maybe 20211 is the same problem.

          Marcel Beister added a comment - - edited Maybe 20211 is the same problem.

          Marcel Beister added a comment -

          This is still a problem in 1.538!

          Marcel Beister added a comment - This is still a problem in 1.538!

          Michael Berman added a comment -

          I also had it working just fine until the latest jenkins update, and now with Throttle 1.8 and Jenkins 1.538 it seems like the plugin just doesn't work at all.

          It also seems broken with Throttle 1.7.2 and 1.7.1 on Jenkins 1.538.

          Michael Berman added a comment - I also had it working just fine until the latest jenkins update, and now with Throttle 1.8 and Jenkins 1.538 it seems like the plugin just doesn't work at all. It also seems broken with Throttle 1.7.2 and 1.7.1 on Jenkins 1.538.

          Michael Berman added a comment -

          Not broken on 1.530.

          Michael Berman added a comment - Not broken on 1.530.

          Marcel Beister added a comment -

          Is this plugin still maintained or shall we look for something new? This bug was reported over a month ago and unfortunately nothing has happened yet. The plugin works find with Jenkins version 1.535 and is broken with all versions starting from 1.536. So I assume something in the api has changed which causes this plugin to fail...

          Marcel Beister added a comment - Is this plugin still maintained or shall we look for something new? This bug was reported over a month ago and unfortunately nothing has happened yet. The plugin works find with Jenkins version 1.535 and is broken with all versions starting from 1.536. So I assume something in the api has changed which causes this plugin to fail...

          Jon Hyman added a comment -

          Same here - it seems to have broken after updating from Jenkins 1.533 to 1.539. I tried updating to 1.540 to see if that fixes it but it is still broken.

          Jon Hyman added a comment - Same here - it seems to have broken after updating from Jenkins 1.533 to 1.539. I tried updating to 1.540 to see if that fixes it but it is still broken.

          Marcel Beister added a comment -

          at least I'm not the only one

          Marcel Beister added a comment - at least I'm not the only one

            abayer Andrew Bayer
            jpschewe jpschewe
            Votes:
            8 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            24 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: