Cannot use jenkins-cli with github oauth plugin

I'm using the github-oauth plugin for authentication and the Github Commiter Authorization Strategy and I'm unable to use the jenkins-cli with it. Running this command:

java -jar jenkins-cli.jar -s http://localhost:8080 who-am-i --username <username> --password <jenkins-api-token> 

results in an error:

"--username" is not a valid option
java -jar jenkins-cli.jar who-am-i
Reports your credential and permissions.

I've also tried ssh key auth with the -i flag but get a similar error about -i being an invalid option.

Is there another way to use jenkins-cli with github auth?