Please add more details. How are the analysis plug-ins in the corresponding job configured? Do you see the results of the analysis plug-ins in the job view?

Attached are screenshots of the config as well as the job output.

I should mention again that I'm not positive I'm even in the right place. I only recently took ownership of this jenkins instance, and was not the person who configured the jobs or the original plugins. So if I'm barking up the wrong tree in terms of what plugin used to provide the "weather" output, please tell me.

Can you please show what's hiding under the advanced button in checkstyle and analysis-collector etc.? There needs to be a value in the health thresholds. If not, then the weather report is not shown...

Ah! I didn't even see those buttons (my browser window was a little too narrow). As it turns out, none of the thresholds were set. I put in 85% and 30% for everything and re-ran the job. Unfortunately, it didn't seem to help. The weather/pop-up still doesn't show any results. Attaching the expanded configs.

Can you please switch the values? It is for the number of warnings for 100% and 0% health, resp. I.e. the number of warnings for 100% should be smaller than the number of warnings for 0%.

I switched the values (actually set them to 0 and 4 respectively) and reran the job to no effect.

Hmm, this works quite well in my setup. Can you please have a look into the build.xml file of your latest build in that project? Are there the correct values filled into the fields of the corresponding plug-ins (replace * with plugin class name):

      <healthDescriptor class="hudson.plugins.*.*HealthDescriptor">
        <priority>LOW</priority>
        <healthy>0</healthy>
        <unHealthy>4</unHealthy>
        ...

Does this occur with all you jobs? Are the jobs freestyle, maven or multi-configuration?

Those do exist in the build.xml for all three plugins. Here's one of the sections:

    <hudson.plugins.findbugs.FindBugsMavenResultAction plugin="findbugs@4.60">
      <defaultEncoding>UTF-8</defaultEncoding>
      <delegate class="hudson.plugins.findbugs.FindBugsResultAction">
        <owner class="hudson.maven.MavenModuleSetBuild" reference="../../../.."/>
        <healthDescriptor class="hudson.plugins.findbugs.FindBugsHealthDescriptor">
          <priority>LOW</priority>
          <healthy>0</healthy>
          <unHealthy>4</unHealthy>
          <thresholds plugin="analysis-core@1.71">
            <unstableTotalAll></unstableTotalAll>
            <unstableTotalHigh></unstableTotalHigh>
            <unstableTotalNormal></unstableTotalNormal>
            <unstableTotalLow></unstableTotalLow>
            <failedTotalAll></failedTotalAll>
            <failedTotalHigh></failedTotalHigh>
            <failedTotalNormal></failedTotalNormal>
            <failedTotalLow></failedTotalLow>
          </thresholds>
        </healthDescriptor>
        <result class="hudson.plugins.findbugs.FindBugsReporterResult">
          <owner class="hudson.maven.MavenModuleSetBuild" reference="../../../../.."/>
          <modules>
            <string>xxxxxxxxxxx-service</string>
          </modules>
          <numberOfModules>1</numberOfModules>
          <defaultEncoding>UTF-8</defaultEncoding>
          <numberOfWarnings>2</numberOfWarnings>
          <numberOfNewWarnings>0</numberOfNewWarnings>
          <numberOfFixedWarnings>0</numberOfFixedWarnings>
          <delta>0</delta>
          <lowDelta>0</lowDelta>
          <normalDelta>0</normalDelta>
          <highDelta>0</highDelta>
          <lowWarnings>0</lowWarnings>
          <normalWarnings>2</normalWarnings>
          <highWarnings>0</highWarnings>
          <zeroWarningsSinceBuild>0</zeroWarningsSinceBuild>
          <zeroWarningsSinceDate>0</zeroWarningsSinceDate>
          <zeroWarningsHighScore>3167719587</zeroWarningsHighScore>
          <isZeroWarningsHighscore>false</isZeroWarningsHighscore>
          <highScoreGap>0</highScoreGap>
          <errors/>
          <pluginResult>SUCCESS</pluginResult>
          <successfulSinceBuild>0</successfulSinceBuild>
          <successfulSinceDate>0</successfulSinceDate>
          <successfulHighscore>0</successfulHighscore>
          <isSuccessfulHighscore>false</isSuccessfulHighscore>
          <successfulHighScoreGap>0</successfulHighScoreGap>
          <isSuccessfulStateTouched>false</isSuccessfulStateTouched>
          <referenceBuild>1369</referenceBuild>
          <newThisWeek>0</newThisWeek>
          <notInCloud>0</notInCloud>
          <numberOfComments>0</numberOfComments>
        </result>
      </delegate>
    </hudson.plugins.findbugs.FindBugsMavenResultAction>

The jobs are all "maven" jobs. Is that an issue?

I figured it out! I was setting the thresholds under "Build Settings" but I hadn't put in thresholds for "Publish combined analysis results". Once I did that, it's working just fine. Thank you so much for your help!

Hmm, actually there should be also a line for each plug-in in the health report (when the health configuration is defined as you have shown above). Strange that these results are not shown, but the collector result is shown...

Ah! Well, my developers are now asking me for the broken-out results to show in the health report as well, so if you have any ideas as to somewhere else I can look I'm all ears.

Works in my test setup (1.611) without any problems. I'll add an acceptance test and see if it behaves differently when used with 1.596.2.

Code changed in jenkins
User: Ulli Hafner
Path:
src/main/java/org/jenkinsci/test/acceptance/plugins/analysis_collector/AnalysisCollectorAction.java
src/main/java/org/jenkinsci/test/acceptance/plugins/analysis_collector/AnalysisCollectorFreestyleBuildSettings.java
src/main/java/org/jenkinsci/test/acceptance/plugins/analysis_collector/AnalysisCollectorSettings.java
src/main/java/org/jenkinsci/test/acceptance/plugins/analysis_core/AnalysisAction.java
src/main/java/org/jenkinsci/test/acceptance/plugins/analysis_core/AnalysisSettings.java
src/main/java/org/jenkinsci/test/acceptance/plugins/checkstyle/CheckStyleAction.java
src/main/java/org/jenkinsci/test/acceptance/plugins/findbugs/FindBugsAction.java
src/main/java/org/jenkinsci/test/acceptance/plugins/pmd/PmdAction.java
src/main/java/org/jenkinsci/test/acceptance/plugins/tasks/TaskScannerAction.java
src/main/java/org/jenkinsci/test/acceptance/plugins/warnings/WarningsAction.java
src/test/java/plugins/AbstractAnalysisTest.java
src/test/java/plugins/AnalysisCollectorPluginTest.java
http://jenkins-ci.org/commit/acceptance-test-harness/b9c687643cc774c6e82de20662fff9b0236c2d82
Log:
JENKINS-28360 Added a test case to verify the health reports.

Is this still a problem in your environment? I just started the new acceptance tests with Jenkins 1.592.2 without any failures.