Details
-
Bug
-
Status: Open (View Workflow)
-
Minor
-
Resolution: Unresolved
Description
Trying the job-restrictions-plugin with Workflow jobs - I added a restriction to master that only jobs matching a regex could run on there. At first glance, that looked perfect - a Workflow job that didn't match that regex stayed in queue while another Workflow job that did match ran fine.
But then I realized that the non-matching job was still sitting in queue, even after another executor not on the master was available. The job is just stuck - it's not even getting to the node { }, etc. If it can't run on master (when master has executors), it just flops around. Ow.
Attachments
Issue Links
- is related to
-
JENKINS-38644 Add the class-name-based job restriction
-
- Resolved
-
-
JENKINS-36626 Support folder plugin with pipeline
-
- Resolved
-
-
-
- Resolved
-
- relates to
-
-
- Resolved
-
Activity
Sam Gleske
added a comment - aszostak I opened a PR addressing the warning you experienced https://github.com/jenkinsci/job-restrictions-plugin/pull/23
Sam Gleske
added a comment - aszostak I opened a PR addressing the warning you experienced https://github.com/jenkinsci/job-restrictions-plugin/pull/23 
Artur Szostak
added a comment - Thank you for the warning fix. Looking forward to seeing the warning disappear in some future upgrade of our Jenkins instance.
Artur Szostak
added a comment - Thank you for the warning fix. Looking forward to seeing the warning disappear in some future upgrade of our Jenkins instance. 
Adrian Vlad
added a comment - I have a similar problem. I have a pipeline called "test_pipeline" and inside it does:
node('some_node') {
...
}
On "some_node" I use Restrict jobs execution at node -> Regular Expression (Job Name) with value test_pipeline.
This configuration doesn't work (the build hangs). But if I change the value to test_pipeline.* then it works.
What is the problem? Is job-restrictions using different pipeline names with some suffix? (test_pipeline/.* also works)
Adrian Vlad
added a comment - I have a similar problem. I have a pipeline called "test_pipeline" and inside it does:
node( 'some_node' ) {
...
}
On "some_node" I use Restrict jobs execution at node -> Regular Expression (Job Name) with value test_pipeline .
This configuration doesn't work (the build hangs). But if I change the value to test_pipeline.* then it works.
What is the problem? Is job-restrictions using different pipeline names with some suffix? ( test_pipeline/.* also works) As stated in https://groups.google.com/d/msg/jenkinsci-dev/uc6NsMoCFQI/AIO4WG1UCwAJ , I have no bandwidth to work on this issue anytime soon. I have marked the plugin for adoption. But I will be happy to review/release anything related to this issue while there is no other maintainer.
aszostak I get that warning too. The primary reason for the error is the class loader for plugins is only populated with related plugins in which it depends. Since the job-restrictions plugin does not directly depend on pipeline plugins, the class loader for it does not include the workflow set of classes. You're right that you can ignore the error and it will "just work". Can probably be considered a bug. It should probably be using the uber classloader which exists in the plugin manager.