'Build only if SCM changes' option doesn't check for build status

ExportXMLWordPrintable

    • Type: Bug
    • Resolution: Postponed
    • Priority: Critical
    • Component/s: multijob-plugin
    • None

      Here is the phase definiton I use: 

      <com.tikal.jenkins.plugins.multijob.MultiJobBuilder>
<phaseName>Develop</phaseName>
<continuationCondition>SUCCESSFUL</continuationCondition>
<phaseJobs>
<com.tikal.jenkins.plugins.multijob.PhaseJobsConfig>
<jobName>delphi-platform-Fast-DSL</jobName>
<currParams>true</currParams>
<exposedSCM>true</exposedSCM>
<disableJob>false</disableJob>
<killPhaseOnJobResultCondition>UNSTABLE</killPhaseOnJobResultCondition>
<abortAllJob>true</abortAllJob>
<configs class="java.util.Collections$EmptyList"></configs>
<buildOnlyIfSCMChanges>true</buildOnlyIfSCMChanges>
</com.tikal.jenkins.plugins.multijob.PhaseJobsConfig>
</phaseJobs>
</com.tikal.jenkins.plugins.multijob.MultiJobBuilder>

      Notice it has killPhaseOnJobResultCondition=UNSTABLE and continuationCondition=SUCCESSFUL

      However one run skipped the subjob execution even though it's result was FAILURE

      12:45:06 [poll] Latest remote head revision on refs/heads/develop is: 9daf17ad24fd88d98585f0f89e96c416d532f4ec - already built by 359
12:45:06     >> Job status: [delphi-platform-Fast-DSL] subjob has no changes since last build.

      You can see the result and actions for said job here: curl $JENKINS_URL'job/delphi-platform-Fast-DSL/359/api/xml?xpath=//*[local-name()=%27result%27%20or%20local-name()=%27action%27]&wrapper=wrapper'

      <wrapper>
<action _class="hudson.model.CauseAction">
<cause _class="hudson.triggers.SCMTrigger$SCMTriggerCause">
<shortDescription>Started by an SCM change</shortDescription>
</cause>
</action>
<action></action>
<action></action>
<action></action>
<action></action>
<action _class="hudson.plugins.git.util.BuildData">
<buildsByBranchName>
<refsremotesorigindevelop _class="hudson.plugins.git.util.Build">
<buildNumber>359</buildNumber>
<marked>
<SHA1>9daf17ad24fd88d98585f0f89e96c416d532f4ec</SHA1>
<branch>
<SHA1>9daf17ad24fd88d98585f0f89e96c416d532f4ec</SHA1>
<name>refs/remotes/origin/develop</name>
</branch>
</marked>
<revision>
<SHA1>9daf17ad24fd88d98585f0f89e96c416d532f4ec</SHA1>
<branch>
<SHA1>9daf17ad24fd88d98585f0f89e96c416d532f4ec</SHA1>
<name>refs/remotes/origin/develop</name>
</branch>
</revision>
</refsremotesorigindevelop>
</buildsByBranchName>
<lastBuiltRevision>
<SHA1>9daf17ad24fd88d98585f0f89e96c416d532f4ec</SHA1>
<branch>
<SHA1>9daf17ad24fd88d98585f0f89e96c416d532f4ec</SHA1>
<name>refs/remotes/origin/develop</name>
</branch>
</lastBuiltRevision>
<remoteUrl>git@git.acme-internal.com:delphi/delphi-platform.git</remoteUrl>
<scmName></scmName>
</action>
<action _class="hudson.plugins.git.GitTagAction"></action>
<action></action>
<action _class="hudson.maven.reporters.MavenAggregatedArtifactRecord"></action>
<action _class="hudson.maven.reporters.SurefireAggregatedReport">
<failCount>0</failCount>
<skipCount>0</skipCount>
<totalCount>227</totalCount>
<urlName>testReport</urlName>
</action>
<action></action>
<action></action>
<action></action>
<result>FAILURE</result>
</wrapper>

      Previous build was STABLE, but there were SCM changes since: curl $JENKINS_URL'job/delphi-platform-Fast-DSL/358/api/xml?xpath=//*[local-name()=%27result%27%20or%20local-name()=%27action%27]&wrapper=wrapper'

      <wrapper>
<action _class="hudson.model.CauseAction">
<cause _class="hudson.triggers.SCMTrigger$SCMTriggerCause">
<shortDescription>Started by an SCM change</shortDescription>
</cause>
</action>
<action></action>
<action></action>
<action></action>
<action></action>
<action _class="hudson.plugins.git.util.BuildData">
<buildsByBranchName>
<refsremotesorigindevelop _class="hudson.plugins.git.util.Build">
<buildNumber>358</buildNumber>
<marked>
<SHA1>55e09e648aa082a05ce1721706e60df2c81cd0a8</SHA1>
<branch>
<SHA1>55e09e648aa082a05ce1721706e60df2c81cd0a8</SHA1>
<name>refs/remotes/origin/develop</name>
</branch>
</marked>
<revision>
<SHA1>55e09e648aa082a05ce1721706e60df2c81cd0a8</SHA1>
<branch>
<SHA1>55e09e648aa082a05ce1721706e60df2c81cd0a8</SHA1>
<name>refs/remotes/origin/develop</name>
</branch>
</revision>
</refsremotesorigindevelop>
</buildsByBranchName>
<lastBuiltRevision>
<SHA1>55e09e648aa082a05ce1721706e60df2c81cd0a8</SHA1>
<branch>
<SHA1>55e09e648aa082a05ce1721706e60df2c81cd0a8</SHA1>
<name>refs/remotes/origin/develop</name>
</branch>
</lastBuiltRevision>
<remoteUrl>git@git.acme-internal.com:delphi/delphi-platform.git</remoteUrl>
<scmName></scmName>
</action>
<action _class="hudson.plugins.git.GitTagAction"></action>
<action></action>
<action _class="hudson.maven.reporters.MavenAggregatedArtifactRecord"></action>
<action _class="hudson.maven.reporters.SurefireAggregatedReport">
<failCount>0</failCount>
<skipCount>0</skipCount>
<totalCount>513</totalCount>
<urlName>testReport</urlName>
</action>
<action></action>
<action _class="hudson.plugins.warnings.WarningsResultAction"></action>
<action _class="hudson.plugins.warnings.AggregatedWarningsResultAction"></action>
<action></action>
<action></action>
<result>SUCCESS</result>
</wrapper>

      I'd expect Multijob to re-run the subjob if last build status is not SUCCESS – I even saw it happening in some cases, but it's not working here

            Assignee:
            Unassigned
            Reporter:
            Jakub Bochenski
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            2 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: