This issue is archived. You can view it, but you can't modify it. Learn more

ExportXMLWordPrintable

      I have tested the tokengroups group-lookup strategy of the (newest) Active Directory Plugin in our AD-environment. Our AD is setup as forest, were some users are located in the root-domain (e.g., root.local), but most user-accounts, security-groups and computers are located in the second resource-domain (e.g., subx.local).

      Therefore, the plugin is currently configured with

      • Domain Name = "subx.local,root.local",
      • Domain controller = "dc1.subx.local:3268,dc2.subx.local:3268"
      • Group Membership Lookup Strategy = "RECURSIVE"

      With this configuration, login "against" a local group of subx.local by using an account of root.local (which is member of the local group) is permitted.

      If I change the the group-lookup strategy to "TOKENGROUPS", the login fails *) ...
      ... and after some tests (with logging 'FINE'), I've determined (or assume), that:

      • Searching for the user-object and login (with credentials) is successful,
      • also getting the tokengroups-list (SIDs) will contain local, universal groups of the subx.local (which DC was asked),
      • But the the name-translation of the tokengroups-SIDs afterwards, is limited to the domain (by Bind-DN) of the user-object. Therefore, the security-groups of our resource-domain (subx.local) were not found!

      *) More concrete:
      Login with an account of the resource-domain (subx.local) is still successful; an much faster.
      The failure/problem occurs only with accounts of the "extra" root-domain.

      Assuming, that my findings/assumptions are correct: It is possible to change the implementation, that groups of "different" (but also configured/permitted domain), are permitted?

      Best regards from Salzburg,
      Markus

            Assignee:
            Félix Belzunce Arcos
            Reporter:
            GMC Software Development B&R Corporate
            Archiver:
            Jenkins Service Account

              Created:
              Updated:
              Archived: