-
Bug
-
Resolution: Fixed
-
Critical
-
None
-
Jenkins = 2.7.3
ez-templates-plugin = 1.2.0
Implementation jobs lost parameters, defined in template job after restart Jenkins.
In template job defined next String parameters:
GITLAB_PROJECT = project
GITLAB_GROUP = group
In implementation job defined next String parameters:
GITLAB_PROJECT = someProject
GITLAB_GROUP = someGroup
Implementation job has checked setting: "Retain local job parameter values"
Its work as expected, bu after restart Jenkins, we see that implementation job lost all parameters.
And than we go to template job and without changes press save it (for sync parameters).
Then go to implementation jobs and enter again default values for this params =(
- duplicates
-
-
- Closed
-
[JENKINS-38965] Implementation jobs lost parameters, defined in template job after restart Jenkins
ellen van ravensteyn
added a comment - Using jenkins 2.89.2
ez templates version 1.3.2
This issue still applies
use case:
job_A is template job with 3 parameters: TEST1, TEST2, TEST3. all with default empty values
job_B implements this template, TEST1 has default value 'test'
in advanced options: 'Retain local job parameter values' is enabled.
All works well untill jenkins restart: after restart all job_B parameters are gone
job_B job configuration still shows 'This project is parameterized', but no parameters available
So it seems on jenkins start-up the parameter load fails.
I created a workaround with a groovy script on jenkins start-up to make sure these parameters appear again, using TemplateUtils.handleTemplateImplementationSaved
based on: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/38726296/using-the-ez-template-plugin-for-jenkins-through-the-jenkins-job-dsl-doesnt-app
After execution of this code: all parameters are again available on job_B, except the default parameter value has disappaered.
So after each jenkins restart, all default values for jobs using the template, have to be re-applied manually.
ellen van ravensteyn
added a comment - Using jenkins 2.89.2
ez templates version 1.3.2
This issue still applies
use case:
job_A is template job with 3 parameters: TEST1, TEST2, TEST3. all with default empty values
job_B implements this template, TEST1 has default value 'test'
in advanced options: 'Retain local job parameter values' is enabled.
All works well untill jenkins restart: after restart all job_B parameters are gone
job_B job configuration still shows 'This project is parameterized', but no parameters available
So it seems on jenkins start-up the parameter load fails.
I created a workaround with a groovy script on jenkins start-up to make sure these parameters appear again, using TemplateUtils.handleTemplateImplementationSaved
based on: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/38726296/using-the-ez-template-plugin-for-jenkins-through-the-jenkins-job-dsl-doesnt-app
After execution of this code: all parameters are again available on job_B, except the default parameter value has disappaered.
So after each jenkins restart, all default values for jobs using the template, have to be re-applied manually.
ellenvr If this (Job DSL vs ez-templates) is still a problem, you need to raise a fresh report with reproducible details. It is not related to the causes of this one which was fixed in 1.2 timeframe
Already fixed Alex. Please upgrade to latest.