Uploaded image for project: 'Jenkins'
  1. Jenkins
  2. JENKINS-44820

Parallel branches with no stage should not be displayed in Blue Ocean

XMLWordPrintable

      With the following pipeline:

      stage("begin") { println "begin" }

parallel (
    "no_stage": { println "no stage" },
    
    "": { println "no name" },
    
    "with_stage": { stage("my_stage") { println "named stage" } }
)

stage("end") { println "end" }

      we are getting the following display in BlueOcean:

      But in the parallel step, only the third branch has a stage defined, and therefore only this one is expected to be displayed. Unfortunately all the branches are displayed even if not containing any stage.
      Additionally, the name displayed for the third branch is the branch name instead of the stage name as one would have thought.

      On the other hand, in the Pipeline view it is displayed as expected:

      Use case: technical steps which need to run in parallel to maintain shared resources, advance timeout monitoring, etc ... doesn't have to pollute the Blue Ocean view.

      May be possible to add a boolean option to the parallel step not to use branch name as default display name in Blue Ocean, and eventually make branch with no stage invisible ?

        1. blueocean.png
          blueocean.png
          9 kB
        2. stages.png
          stages.png
          19 kB
        3. [JENKINS-44820] Parallel branches with no stage should not be displayed in Blue Ocean - Jenkins JIRA 2017-06-22 14-18-59.png
          [JENKINS-44820] Parallel branches with no stage should not be displayed in Blue Ocean - Jenkins JIRA 2017-06-22 14-18-59.png
          9 kB
        4. image-2017-06-22-12-33-47-644.png
          image-2017-06-22-12-33-47-644.png
          5 kB
        5. image-2017-06-22-12-47-13-324.png
          image-2017-06-22-12-47-13-324.png
          9 kB
        6. image-2017-06-22-12-53-45-573.png
          image-2017-06-22-12-53-45-573.png
          8 kB

          [JENKINS-44820] Parallel branches with no stage should not be displayed in Blue Ocean

          Jean-Paul G created issue -
          Jean-Paul G made changes -
          Description Original: With the following pipeline:
          {code:java}
          stage("begin") { println "begin" }

          parallel (
              "no_stage": { println "no stage" },
              
              "": { println "no name" },
              
              "with_stage": { stage("my_stage") { println "named stage" } }
          )

          stage("end") { println "end" }
          {code}
          we are getting the following display in BlueOcean:

          !blueocean.png!

          But in the parallel step, only the third step as a *stage* defined, and therefore only this one is expected to be displayed. Unfortunately all the branches are displayed even if not containing any stage

          Typically in the Pipeline view it is displayed as expected:

          !stages.png!

          Use case: technical steps which need to run in parallel to maintain shared resources, advance timeout monitoring, etc ... doesn't have to pollute the Blue Ocean view.           		New: With the following pipeline:
          {code:java}
          stage("begin") { println "begin" }

          parallel (
              "no_stage": { println "no stage" },
              
              "": { println "no name" },
              
              "with_stage": { stage("my_stage") { println "named stage" } }
          )

          stage("end") { println "end" }
          {code}
          we are getting the following display in BlueOcean:

          !blueocean.png!

          But in the parallel step, only the third branch has a *stage* defined, and therefore only this one is expected to be displayed. Unfortunately all the branches are displayed even if not containing any stage.
          Additionally, the name displayed for the third branch is the *branch name* instead of the *stage name* as one would have thought.

          On the other hand, in the Pipeline view it is displayed as expected:

          !stages.png!

          Use case: technical steps which need to run in parallel to maintain shared resources, advance timeout monitoring, etc ... doesn't have to pollute the Blue Ocean view.

          May be possible to add an boolean option to the parallel step not to use branch name as default display name in Blue Ocean ?
          Jean-Paul G made changes -
          Description Original: With the following pipeline:
          {code:java}
          stage("begin") { println "begin" }

          parallel (
              "no_stage": { println "no stage" },
              
              "": { println "no name" },
              
              "with_stage": { stage("my_stage") { println "named stage" } }
          )

          stage("end") { println "end" }
          {code}
          we are getting the following display in BlueOcean:

          !blueocean.png!

          But in the parallel step, only the third branch has a *stage* defined, and therefore only this one is expected to be displayed. Unfortunately all the branches are displayed even if not containing any stage.
          Additionally, the name displayed for the third branch is the *branch name* instead of the *stage name* as one would have thought.

          On the other hand, in the Pipeline view it is displayed as expected:

          !stages.png!

          Use case: technical steps which need to run in parallel to maintain shared resources, advance timeout monitoring, etc ... doesn't have to pollute the Blue Ocean view.

          May be possible to add an boolean option to the parallel step not to use branch name as default display name in Blue Ocean ?           		New: With the following pipeline:
          {code:java}
          stage("begin") { println "begin" }

          parallel (
              "no_stage": { println "no stage" },
              
              "": { println "no name" },
              
              "with_stage": { stage("my_stage") { println "named stage" } }
          )

          stage("end") { println "end" }
          {code}
          we are getting the following display in BlueOcean:

          !blueocean.png!

          But in the parallel step, only the third branch has a *stage* defined, and therefore only this one is expected to be displayed. Unfortunately all the branches are displayed even if not containing any stage.
          Additionally, the name displayed for the third branch is the *branch name* instead of the *stage name* as one would have thought.

          On the other hand, in the Pipeline view it is displayed as expected:

          !stages.png!

          Use case: technical steps which need to run in parallel to maintain shared resources, advance timeout monitoring, etc ... doesn't have to pollute the Blue Ocean view.

          May be possible to add a boolean option to the parallel step not to use branch name as default display name in Blue Ocean ?
          Jean-Paul G made changes -
          Description Original: With the following pipeline:
          {code:java}
          stage("begin") { println "begin" }

          parallel (
              "no_stage": { println "no stage" },
              
              "": { println "no name" },
              
              "with_stage": { stage("my_stage") { println "named stage" } }
          )

          stage("end") { println "end" }
          {code}
          we are getting the following display in BlueOcean:

          !blueocean.png!

          But in the parallel step, only the third branch has a *stage* defined, and therefore only this one is expected to be displayed. Unfortunately all the branches are displayed even if not containing any stage.
          Additionally, the name displayed for the third branch is the *branch name* instead of the *stage name* as one would have thought.

          On the other hand, in the Pipeline view it is displayed as expected:

          !stages.png!

          Use case: technical steps which need to run in parallel to maintain shared resources, advance timeout monitoring, etc ... doesn't have to pollute the Blue Ocean view.

          May be possible to add a boolean option to the parallel step not to use branch name as default display name in Blue Ocean ?           		New: With the following pipeline:
          {code:java}
          stage("begin") { println "begin" }

          parallel (
              "no_stage": { println "no stage" },
              
              "": { println "no name" },
              
              "with_stage": { stage("my_stage") { println "named stage" } }
          )

          stage("end") { println "end" }
          {code}
          we are getting the following display in BlueOcean:

          !blueocean.png!

          But in the parallel step, only the third branch has a *stage* defined, and therefore only this one is expected to be displayed. Unfortunately all the branches are displayed even if not containing any stage.
          Additionally, the name displayed for the third branch is the *branch name* instead of the *stage name* as one would have thought.

          On the other hand, in the Pipeline view it is displayed as expected:

          !stages.png!

          Use case: technical steps which need to run in parallel to maintain shared resources, advance timeout monitoring, etc ... doesn't have to pollute the Blue Ocean view.

          May be possible to add a boolean option to the parallel step not to use branch name as default display name in Blue Ocean, and eventually make branch with no stage invisible ?
          James Dumay made changes -
          Epic Link New: JENKINS-43953 [ 181485 ]
          Jean-Paul G made changes -
          Link New: This issue is related to JENKINS-38442 [ JENKINS-38442 ]
          Jean-Paul G made changes -
          Attachment New: image-2017-06-22-12-33-47-644.png [ 38583 ]
          Jean-Paul G made changes -
          Attachment New: image-2017-06-22-12-47-13-324.png [ 38584 ]
          Jean-Paul G made changes -
          Attachment New: image-2017-06-22-12-53-45-573.png [ 38585 ]
          Paolo Brocco made changes -
          Link New: This issue is related to JENKINS-47473 [ JENKINS-47473 ]

            Unassigned Unassigned
            jguigui Jean-Paul G
            Votes:
            3 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            4 Start watching this issue

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved: