-
Bug
-
Resolution: Fixed
-
Minor
Acceptance Test Harness does not restart when installing plugins requiring newer deps than installed plugins. So I get collisions since some plugins cannot load due to the missing deps
https://ci.jenkins.io/blue/organizations/jenkins/Plugins%2Fartifact-manager-s3-plugin/detail/PR-20/5... .
- relates to
-
JENKINS-36441 Provide an engine for plugin bundling in the Jenkins2 core
-
- Open
-
[JENKINS-51306] ATH does not restart instance when withPlugin() requires newer dependency than the bundled version
By taking a look at the video and by my local debugging I can confirm that the ATH does restart Jenkins, however, that restart seems to have no effect on the status of the plugin, this is quite strange. I am going to try to reproduce locally (without ATH) to see if is something related to the use of a custom update center or the war itself
I can confirm this is not an ATH failure, even when starting the war file by itself and trying to update the plugin manually (via UC) it does restart but is not updated... Trying to understand why
Likely the bundling functionality does not behave properly since changes around 2.0
And now I remember that I was doing a patch for JENKINS-36441 (https://github.com/jenkinsci/jenkins/pull/2436/files), which is likely related to the behavior of the plugin manager
Confirmed, with the following BOM all failures related to plugins not being installed are solved
metadata:
# labels and annotations are key: value string attributes
labels:
name: bom-it
# Needed to make PCT happy
groupId: org.jenkins-ci.main
artifactId: jenkins-war
version: 2.118-artifact-manager-s3-SNAPSHOT
spec:
core:
version: 2.118
plugins:
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins.workflow"
artifactId: "workflow-api"
version: 2.28-rc333.0675e9e9cb4c
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins"
artifactId: "copyartifact"
version: 1.40-rc298.60da56cfabea
# Maven HPI Plugin improperly resolves dependency trees, needs upper bounds check
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins"
artifactId: "structs"
version: 1.14
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins.workflow"
artifactId: "workflow-step-api"
version: 2.14
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins.workflow"
artifactId: "workflow-job"
version: 2.21
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins.workflow"
artifactId: "workflow-basic-steps"
version: 2.7
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins.workflow"
artifactId: "workflow-support"
version: 2.18
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins"
artifactId: "junit"
version: 1.24
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins"
artifactId: "mailer"
version: 1.21
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins"
artifactId: "scm-api"
version: 2.2.7
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins"
artifactId: "script-security"
version: 1.44
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins"
artifactId: "aws-java-sdk"
version: 1.11.264
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins"
artifactId: "apache-httpcomponents-client-4-api"
version: 4.5.5-2.0
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins"
artifactId: "matrix-project"
version: 1.7.1
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins"
artifactId: "jackson2-api"
version: 2.8.11.2
- groupId: "org.jenkins-ci.plugins"
artifactId: "display-url-api"
version: 2.2.0
environments:
- name: aws
plugins:
#TODO: BOM does not support FileSystem REFs, so somebody needs to add BOM auto-update logic here
- groupId: "io.jenkins.plugins"
artifactId: "artifact-manager-s3"
version: 1.0-alpha-1-rc20.60688a35a736
jglick Made a very interesting (and right IMO) statement in a conversation
if the plugin is bundled by the CWP, then by definition you do _not_ want to update it
That means if any transitive one is on the wrong version, you should add explicitly on the right one. As a corollary from that (which I can agree also) in the end we are (IMO) going to need a tool to update/generate the BOM file automatically or maintaining it is going to be so impractical that nobody is going to do that, again jglick has pointed to https://issues.jenkins-ci.org/browse/JENKINS-47498 for that
oleg_nenashev Closing this as it seems not related to the ATH itself
The problem is not on the ATH itself, and the root cause needs discussion about the way to be solved