• Type: Bug
• Resolution: Fixed
• Priority: Major
• Component/s: p4-plugin
• Labels:

  None
• Environment:

  Hudson 1.383
  Perforce plugin 1.1.11
  p4 Rev. P4/LINUX26X86/2009.1/205670 (2009/06/29)

[JENKINS-8064] Perforce plugin incorrectly finds changes

ickersep created issue - 2010-11-10 08:54

ickersep made changes - 2010-11-10 08:55

Description

Original: I have a project that hasn't changed (no checkins to Perforce), building on a slave (that hasn't changed either). Yet the P4 plugin thinks there are changes and kicks off a build several times a day. The polling log shows: Started on Nov 10, 2010 9:29:10 AM Looking for changes... Using node: builder-ubuntu-jaunty-32-nutmeg Using remote perforce client: hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 [unitpp-Linux-32] $ /usr/local/bin/p4 workspace -o hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 Changing P4 Client Root to: /home/boss/hudson/workspace/unitpp-Linux-32 Changing P4 Client View from: Changing P4 Client View to:   //depot/External/unit++/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/...   -//depot/External/unit++/Lib/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Lib/...   -//depot/External/unit++/Include/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Include/... Done. Took 0.45 sec Changes found

New: I have a project that hasn't changed (no checkins to Perforce), building on a slave (that hasn't changed either). Yet the P4 plugin thinks there are changes and kicks off a build several times a day. The polling log shows: Started on Nov 10, 2010 9:29:10 AM Looking for changes... Using node: builder-ubuntu-jaunty-32-nutmeg Using remote perforce client: hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 [unitpp-Linux-32] $ /usr/local/bin/p4 workspace -o hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 Changing P4 Client Root to: /home/boss/hudson/workspace/unitpp-Linux-32 Changing P4 Client View from: Changing P4 Client View to:   //depot/External/unit++/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/...   '-//depot/External/unit++/Lib/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Lib/...   '-//depot/External/unit++/Include/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Include/... Done. Took 0.45 sec Changes found

ickersep made changes - 2010-11-10 08:55

Description

Original: I have a project that hasn't changed (no checkins to Perforce), building on a slave (that hasn't changed either). Yet the P4 plugin thinks there are changes and kicks off a build several times a day. The polling log shows: Started on Nov 10, 2010 9:29:10 AM Looking for changes... Using node: builder-ubuntu-jaunty-32-nutmeg Using remote perforce client: hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 [unitpp-Linux-32] $ /usr/local/bin/p4 workspace -o hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 Changing P4 Client Root to: /home/boss/hudson/workspace/unitpp-Linux-32 Changing P4 Client View from: Changing P4 Client View to:   //depot/External/unit++/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/...   '-//depot/External/unit++/Lib/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Lib/...   '-//depot/External/unit++/Include/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Include/... Done. Took 0.45 sec Changes found

New: I have a project that hasn't changed (no checkins to Perforce), building on a slave (that hasn't changed either). Yet the P4 plugin thinks there are changes and kicks off a build several times a day. The polling log shows: Started on Nov 10, 2010 9:29:10 AM Looking for changes... Using node: builder-ubuntu-jaunty-32-nutmeg Using remote perforce client: hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 [unitpp-Linux-32] $ /usr/local/bin/p4 workspace -o hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 Changing P4 Client Root to: /home/boss/hudson/workspace/unitpp-Linux-32 Changing P4 Client View from: Changing P4 Client View to:   //depot/External/unit++/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/...   -//depot/External/unit++/Lib/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Lib/...   \-//depot/External/unit++/Include/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Include/... Done. Took 0.45 sec Changes found

ickersep made changes - 2010-11-10 08:56

Description

Original: I have a project that hasn't changed (no checkins to Perforce), building on a slave (that hasn't changed either). Yet the P4 plugin thinks there are changes and kicks off a build several times a day. The polling log shows: Started on Nov 10, 2010 9:29:10 AM Looking for changes... Using node: builder-ubuntu-jaunty-32-nutmeg Using remote perforce client: hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 [unitpp-Linux-32] $ /usr/local/bin/p4 workspace -o hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 Changing P4 Client Root to: /home/boss/hudson/workspace/unitpp-Linux-32 Changing P4 Client View from: Changing P4 Client View to:   //depot/External/unit++/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/...   -//depot/External/unit++/Lib/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Lib/...   \-//depot/External/unit++/Include/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Include/... Done. Took 0.45 sec Changes found

New: I have a project that hasn't changed (no checkins to Perforce), building on a slave (that hasn't changed either). Yet the P4 plugin thinks there are changes and kicks off a build several times a day. The polling log shows: Started on Nov 10, 2010 9:29:10 AM Looking for changes... Using node: builder-ubuntu-jaunty-32-nutmeg Using remote perforce client: hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 [unitpp-Linux-32] $ /usr/local/bin/p4 workspace -o hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 Changing P4 Client Root to: /home/boss/hudson/workspace/unitpp-Linux-32 Changing P4 Client View from: Changing P4 Client View to:   //depot/External/unit++/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/...   \-//depot/External/unit++/Lib/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Lib/...   \-//depot/External/unit++/Include/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Include/... Done. Took 0.45 sec Changes found

ickersep made changes - 2010-11-10 08:56

Description

Original: I have a project that hasn't changed (no checkins to Perforce), building on a slave (that hasn't changed either). Yet the P4 plugin thinks there are changes and kicks off a build several times a day. The polling log shows: Started on Nov 10, 2010 9:29:10 AM Looking for changes... Using node: builder-ubuntu-jaunty-32-nutmeg Using remote perforce client: hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 [unitpp-Linux-32] $ /usr/local/bin/p4 workspace -o hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 Changing P4 Client Root to: /home/boss/hudson/workspace/unitpp-Linux-32 Changing P4 Client View from: Changing P4 Client View to:   //depot/External/unit++/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/...   \-//depot/External/unit++/Lib/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Lib/...   \-//depot/External/unit++/Include/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Include/... Done. Took 0.45 sec Changes found

New: I have a project that hasn't changed (no checkins to Perforce), building on a slave (that hasn't changed either). Yet the P4 plugin thinks there are changes and kicks off a build several times a day. The polling log shows: Started on Nov 10, 2010 9:29:10 AM Looking for changes... Using node: builder-ubuntu-jaunty-32-nutmeg Using remote perforce client: hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 [unitpp-Linux-32] $ /usr/local/bin/p4 workspace \-o hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 Changing P4 Client Root to: /home/boss/hudson/workspace/unitpp-Linux-32 Changing P4 Client View from: Changing P4 Client View to:   //depot/External/unit++/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/...   \-//depot/External/unit++/Lib/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Lib/...   \-//depot/External/unit++/Include/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Include/... Done. Took 0.45 sec Changes found

ickersep made changes - 2010-11-10 09:05

Description	Original: I have a project that hasn't changed (no checkins to Perforce), building on a slave (that hasn't changed either). Yet the P4 plugin thinks there are changes and kicks off a build several times a day. The polling log shows: Started on Nov 10, 2010 9:29:10 AM Looking for changes... Using node: builder-ubuntu-jaunty-32-nutmeg Using remote perforce client: hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 [unitpp-Linux-32] $ /usr/local/bin/p4 workspace \-o hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 Changing P4 Client Root to: /home/boss/hudson/workspace/unitpp-Linux-32 Changing P4 Client View from: Changing P4 Client View to:   //depot/External/unit++/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/...   \-//depot/External/unit++/Lib/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Lib/...   \-//depot/External/unit++/Include/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Include/... Done. Took 0.45 sec Changes found	New: I have a project that hasn't changed (no checkins to Perforce), building on a slave (that hasn't changed either). Yet the P4 plugin thinks there are changes and kicks off a build several times a day. The polling log shows: Started on Nov 10, 2010 9:29:10 AM Looking for changes... Using node: builder-ubuntu-jaunty-32-nutmeg Using remote perforce client: hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 [unitpp-Linux-32] $ /usr/local/bin/p4 workspace \-o hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900 Changing P4 Client Root to: /home/boss/hudson/workspace/unitpp-Linux-32 Changing P4 Client View from: Changing P4 Client View to:   //depot/External/unit++/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/...   \-//depot/External/unit++/Lib/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Lib/...   \-//depot/External/unit++/Include/... //hudson-unitpp-linux32--497286900/Include/... Done. Took 0.45 sec Changes found
Environment		New: Hudson 1.383 Perforce plugin 1.1.11 p4 Rev. P4/LINUX26X86/2009.1/205670 (2009/06/29)

Collapse comment: Rob Petti added a comment - 2010-11-10 12:39, Edited by Rob Petti - 2010-11-10 12:49

Rob Petti added a comment - 2010-11-10 12:39 - edited

Do changes show up in the changelog of the resulting build?

Also, does this happen every time the polling runs, or only intermittently? Hudson 1.378 introduced a major master-slave communication issue that is adversely affecting the perforce plugin. It has yet to be fixed, so you will experience problems if you are using the perforce plugin with slaves.

Expand comment: Rob Petti added a comment - 2010-11-10 12:39, Edited by Rob Petti - 2010-11-10 12:49

Rob Petti added a comment - 2010-11-10 12:39 - edited Do changes show up in the changelog of the resulting build? Also, does this happen every time the polling runs, or only intermittently? Hudson 1.378 introduced a major master-slave communication issue that is adversely affecting the perforce plugin. It has yet to be fixed, so you will experience problems if you are using the perforce plugin with slaves.

Rob Petti made changes - 2010-11-10 12:39

Assignee

New: Rob Petti [ rpetti ]

Collapse comment: ickersep added a comment - 2010-11-10 14:01

ickersep added a comment - 2010-11-10 14:01

No, no changes show up anywhere.

It happens intermittently. It might very well be that it is related to the master/slave communication issue. I think it started after I upgraded 1.377 to 1.383.

I downgraded to 1.377 and will see if the problem still happens.

Do you have a bug number for this master/slave communication bug?

Expand comment: ickersep added a comment - 2010-11-10 14:01

ickersep added a comment - 2010-11-10 14:01 No, no changes show up anywhere. It happens intermittently. It might very well be that it is related to the master/slave communication issue. I think it started after I upgraded 1.377 to 1.383. I downgraded to 1.377 and will see if the problem still happens. Do you have a bug number for this master/slave communication bug?

Collapse comment: Rob Petti added a comment - 2010-11-10 15:59

Rob Petti added a comment - 2010-11-10 15:59

JENKINS-7809 is the root cause, and JENKINS-7664 is another symptom.

Expand comment: Rob Petti added a comment - 2010-11-10 15:59

Rob Petti added a comment - 2010-11-10 15:59 JENKINS-7809 is the root cause, and JENKINS-7664 is another symptom.

Load more newer events