[JENKINS-47418] Pipeline input visual inconsistency

Type: Bug
Resolution: Duplicate
Priority: Minor
Component/s: blueocean-plugin, pipeline-input-step-plugin, pipeline-stage-view-plugin
Labels:
None

Similar Issues:
Powered by SuggestiMate

Show

The markup for a Pipeline's input step is rendered inconsistently depending on the UI. They're all bad in their own ways. It makes it hard to build good experiences for users.

Here, you can see discrepencies between: how the message is formatted. Should it be plaintext or HTML? Similiarly for text area inputs, shouldn't it use textareas everywhere?

Here's a sample Pipeline Job:

def message = "Hello!"
def stackProperties = [
  app_name: "asdf",
  app_version: "1234" 
]

stage("Hello") {
  input(
    message: message + "\n\nWrite a short description of the release notes (think customer facing). Supports slack formatting",
    parameters: [text(name: 'deploy-notes', defaultValue: """Deploying
${stackProperties.app_name}@${stackProperties.app_version}
*Changes*:
-

*Impact*:
- none""")],
    submitterParameter: 'PASSES_QA_APPROVER'
  )
}

I've attached some screenshots of the three places where I see inputs: